Below, please find the latest High-Volume ETF Cutline
report, which shows how far above or below their respective long-term trend
lines (39-week SMA) my currently tracked ETFs are positioned.
This report covers the HV ETF Master List from Thursday’s
StatSheet and includes 322 High Volume ETFs, defined as those with an average
daily volume of more than $5 million, of which currently 32 (last week 33) are
hovering in bullish territory. The yellow line separates those ETFs that are
positioned above their trend line (%M/A) from those that have dropped below it.
In case you are not familiar
with some of the terminology used in the reports, please read the Glossary of Terms.
If you missed the original
post about the Cutline approach, you can read it here.
It
could have been a lot worse with equities churning lower today, but thanks to Monday’s
surge, the weekly effect was relatively minor with the S&P 500 “only” surrendering
a modest -2%, which is tiny when compared to the recent wild rides we’ve seen.
Even
the March jobs disaster, as Zero Hedge called it, showed that 701k
jobs were lost, while the unemployment
rate soared the most in 45 years. As was no surprise, private
service and leisure
were the hardest hit areas.
Keep
in mind, the numbers were much higher, because the survey was taken around
March 13 and ahead of the big shutdown and layoff announcements. That means the
next set of numbers for April due out in May will indeed be epic, with some
analysts forecasting a loss of as many as 10 million jobs.
It
seems that oil’s
recent rally, which continued today, helped support equities to some degree,
as hopes of a supply cut sparked the single-biggest daily gain ever and the biggest
weekly gain ever in crude oil, as ZH reports. They further summed up the stories
of the week this way:
Helicopter money
begins… and the sovereign risk of the USA soars
Oil has best week
ever on hopes of supply cut.
Stocks sink as any
rebalance flow support evaporated.
Lockdown effects are
starting to be seen in labor and survey data
In
the end, the major indexes are still hovering at a level inconsistent with underlying
fundamentals. In the case of the Dow, forward earnings per share (EPS) would
put this index just below the 15k level, as this
chart from Bloomberg demonstrates. This translates into a drop of some 30%
from current readings.
Who
knows if it will get there? However, being in a bear market, you can’t simply discount
this possibility.
1. From the universe of over 1,800 ETFs, I have selected only those with a
trading volume of over $5 million per day (HV ETFs), so that liquidity and a
small bid/ask spread are assured.
2. Trend Tracking Indexes (TTIs)
Buy or Sell decisions for Domestic and International ETFs (section 1 and
2), are made based on the respective TTI and its position either above or below
its long-term M/A (Moving Average). A crossing of the trend line from below
accompanied by some staying power above constitutes a “Buy” signal. Conversely,
a clear break below the line constitutes a “Sell” signal. Additionally, I use a
7.5% trailing stop loss on all positions in these categories to control
downside risk.
3. All other investment arenas do not have a TTI and should be traded
based on the position of the individual
ETF relative to its own respective trend line (%M/A). That’s why those signals
are referred to as a “Selective Buy.” In other words, if an ETF crosses its own
trendline to the upside, a “Buy” signal is generated. Since these areas tend to
be more volatile, I recommend a wider trailing sell stop of 7.5% -10% depending
on your risk tolerance.
If you are unfamiliar with some of the terminology, please see Glossary of Termsand new subscriber information in section 9.
1. DOMESTIC EQUITY ETFs: SELL
— since 02/27/2020
Click on chart to enlarge
Our main directional indicator, the Domestic Trend Tracking Index (TTI-green line in the above chart) is now positioned below its long-term trend line (red) by -24.22% after having generated a new Domestic “Sell” signal effective 2/27/20 as posted.
The futures markets crashed
into the red last night, despite a strong start to the session. The cause was another
unprecedented surge in initial jobless claims, after last week’s record 3.3
million rise, but this week, we added 6.648
million for a two-week grand total of 10 million new people claiming unemployment
benefits, as ZeroHedge pointed out.
So, what do you do when you know the markets are about to
get slaughtered again?
You create a rumor. And that is exactly what the White House
did, as Trump tweeted this:
Just spoke to my friend MBS (Crown Prince) of
Saudi Arabia, who spoke with President Putin of Russia, & I expect &
hope that they will be cutting back approximately 10 Million Barrels, and maybe
substantially more which, if it happens, will be GREAT for the oil & gas
industry!
That’s all it took to shift the computer algos into high hear
with the Dow at one point being up some 500 points, after which it lost all of
its gains and dipped below the unchanged line before recovering and storming back
towards the highs of the day.
ZeroHedge clarified the events as follows:
The mid-day volatility was a result of Russia’s energy
minister emphasizing that instead of cutting supply, Russia will wait for demand
to return.
The Dow Jones news service made it clear that, according
to Saudi sources, Trump’s tweet was nothing but a baseless oil price manipulation:
SAUDI OFFICIAL SAY TRUMP’S TALK OF 10 MILLION BBL A DAY CUT OR ABOVE WAS AN EXAGGERATION
Finally, Moscow confirmed where to expect the oil prices
in the coming year:
RUSSIA IS SAID TO BASE REVISED 2020 BUDGET PLAN ON $20 OIL
After all this, it makes me laugh out loud how oil prices
could have gained 23% and stocks participated with an over 2% advance, while 10
million Americans lost their jobs in 2 weeks’ time.
Maybe, it was simply another overdue dead-cat bounce.
As the worst quarter in history came to an end with a
sell-off, the 2nd quarter started with a bang—but to the downside, leaving
the always optimistic Wall Street players gasping. As Barron’s commented, today
was the worst first day of a quarter—ever. That’s a lot of “worsts,” and they erased
some 50% of last week’s dead-cat-bounce.
Today, there simply was no bullish meat found on that
ageing carcass, with the major indexes spending the entire session below their
respective unchanged lines giving the bears an easy victory, as any rally
attempts ran into a brick wall of selling.
For sure, not helping matters was Trump’s warning that a “very,
very painful” two weeks lie ahead, as we continue to face the rapidly
spreading coronavirus epidemic. That indicates that many businesses will remain
shut down for at least that period, but I think that timeframe will be extended.
It is now clear that the world’s economies have been and
are experiencing a never seen before interruption to industries, small businesses
and households, even far worse than what we saw in 2008. The hope that a
V-shape type of recovery will be in our near future may not happen, if this
shutdown extends for any length of time past the month of April.
Last week’s bullish driver, namely the quarter-end rebalancing
act, is now spent and in the rear-view mirror. Another major player that has
heavily contributed to the bullish theme over the past few years, corporate buybacks,
have disappeared as well with companies having more serious issues than manipulating
their stock price via the buyback game.
That leaves economic data, and possibly the Plunge Protection
Team (PPP),
to offer market support, the power of either is questionable given current
circumstances.
No, I am not being negative. I see a light at the end of
the tunnel, the tunnel is just much longer than most anticipate.
An early rebound hit a brick wall, as this month/quarter turned
out to be nothing but misery for the buy-and-hold crowd. To wit, during March,
the major indexes lost big time with the S&P 500 plunging -12.5% vs. 0% for
those who followed my trend tracking guidelines, which called for “all cash” effective
2/27/20.
Keep in mind that the -12.5% loss for the S&P 500 happened
despite a huge rebound last week, which was powered by massive quarterly-ending
rebalancing efforts. Otherwise, the index would have been down over 30%. In the
end, the S&P 500 ended “only” down some -20% for the quarter. Ouch!
Much of this market deterioration has been blamed on the coronavirus,
but this virus was merely a bug in search of a windshield, and it finally found
one. As I posted before, the financial markets were long overdue for a serious correction,
and Covid-19 was purely the pin that pricked the bubble.
Helping today’s early bullish theme were preliminary reports
of what’s in store with consumer confidence, Chicago PMI and Chinese manufacturing,
which were coming in better than expected, but I don’t think that encompasses the
month of March, during which econ numbers look to have taken a steep dive with
the country shutting down.
ZeroHedge posted the question: So, how bad was Q1? And
answered it with this
chart confirming that it was the world’s biggest quarterly
capitalization loss in bonds and stocksever…during which stocks lost
a record-smashing $19.6 trillion…
So, the big question is “how low can we go?” While no one
has that answer, one argument is that markets need to adjust to forward earnings.
If that is true, as Bloomberg demonstrates in this
chart, somewhere in the neighborhood of 1,600 for the S&P 500 might be
a stopping point.
No one knows if that will happen, but I think it’s a
possibility, so my preference, for the time being, is watching this develop
from the sidelines.