An early morning pop gave way to a drop,
which gave way to a slow but steady recovery with the major indexes managing to
reclaim their respective unchanged lines by a small margin.
What caused the comeback? Nothing noteworthy, other than a
China trade spokesperson uttering the words that computer algos thrive on, namely
that the so-called phase 1 negotiations designed to cease tariff hostilities, are
“progressing.”
But the spokesman emphasized China’s desire to make
existing tariff rollbacks a part of any resolution, which may not sit well with
the White House. As a result, the tug-of-war to save face is bound to continue.
On deck tomorrow will be the always eagerly anticipated jobs
report with the consensus forecast calling for a gain of 180k new jobs. Anything
close to that number will likely give the markets a boost, unless bad trade
news provides the bears with something to cheer about.
Today was reversal day, as the trade soap opera story was
changed again based on an unsourced rumor that a phase-1 deal was still in the works.
Even though nothing of substance was offered, it was enough hope for the computer
algos to shift in reverse and pull the markets out of the doldrums.
One analyst summed up the trade story like this:
President Trump stated he is
in no rush and “in some ways I think it’s better to wait until after the
election” to make a trade deal with China. Not September, as we were told by
those ‘in the know’ at certain financial media; not October, as were again
told; not November, as we were still told; and not December, and perhaps not
early 2020 – but after the US presidential election….which might as well be
forever for markets.
Especially as Trump will not
have any electoral concerns at that point so might just dump the whole idea and
go ‘all-in’. Indeed, Commerce Secretary Ross also made clear if “substantial
progress” isn’t seen soon then the final 15% tariff tranche is indeed going to
happen on 15 December.
And so, the saga goes on. The major indexes popped nicely
but gave back some of their early gains, as momentum faded into the close. The market-implied
odds of a trade deal rebounded and are now at about 50/50, which is more or
less a coin-flip, while they were at 70% just in early November, according to ZH.
Helping today’s rebound was a double whammy short
squeeze, while the decoupling
of stocks and bonds, which I posted yesterday, continued despite stocks almost touching
the 10-year bond yield, which gained 5.3 basis points to end the day at 1.772%.
Since the Fed has made its policy of lower interest rates
clear, the stock indexes are now dependent on the latest rumors from the trade
front. And I am sure, they will continue to be full of surprises.
As I pondered
yesterday, the While House indeed fired the next salvo about the trade talks,
but it was not what the markets expected. Stocks got hit hard when Trump
announced that the idea of holding off on a US-China trade deal until after
the 2020 election was appealing.
This
undermined confidence and hope, by traders and computer algos alike, that a
deal may be completed before new import tariffs are scheduled to be imposed by
December 15.
At the
same time, the US threatened 100% tariffs on some $2.4 billion in French goods
over their digital tax, which has adversely affected US tech companies. Additionally,
potential tariffs on countries like Brazil and Argentina were on the menu as
well.
That
seemed to conclude or end, at least for the time being, the game of endless
headlines spouting the “a trade deal is close” theme designed to pump the
markets to ever new highs.
Especially
the past two days have seen a sudden and dramatic reversal in sentiment, as a
result of less-than-positive trade deal comments. The market implied odds of a
trade deal have now plunged.
One of
Nomura’s analysts summed it up this way:
“What forced
self-reinforcing buying pressure on the way up is about to feed a vicious cycle
of selling on the way down.”
That simply means some
of the big players are chomping at the bit to short the markets, but only once
a certain level has been hit. So, great news, such as the good old standby “a
trade deal is close,” are sorely needed, in order to stem current downside momentum.
The
10-year bond yield collapsed 10.6 basis points to end at 1.72%. That’s a huge
move, and it finally showed the discrepancy between bond yields and the Dow narrowing
dramatically, as ZH pointed out with this
chart. The S&P 500 had its worst
start to a December since 2008. A tip of the hat goes to Bloomberg for this
graph.
While
we witnessed a slow crawl back from the day’s lows, it was not nearly enough to
get back to even, as the possibility of a postponed trade deal was simply too much
of a negative to overcome.
Just as I posted the amazing fact last Wednesday that the
S&P 500 had not corrected more than -0.5% in 35 days, it happened suddenly
with the index shedding a moderate -0.86%.
The markets got hit right at the opening with a one-two
punch in form of a worse-than-expected manufacturing report and mixed comments
on the latest involving the US-China trade tensions.
The ISM manufacturing index dropped to 48.1% from 48.3%
in October against expectations of an overly optimistic 49.2%. Readings below
50% indicate that business conditions are getting worse.
AS ZH reports, a quadruple whammy of not-awesome trade related
comments gave an assist to the bears:
0602ET *TRUMP TO RESTORE TARIFF ON STEEL
SHIPPED FROM BRAZIL, ARGENTINA
1035ET *TRUMP WILL INCREASE TARIFFS IF NO
CHINA DEAL, ROSS TELLS FOX
1200ET *TRUMP AIDE SAYS IT’S UP TO CHINA IF
DEAL WILL BE MADE THIS YR
1230ET *CHINA TO RELEASE ‘UNRELIABLE ENTITY
LIST’: GLOBAL TIMES
As a result, domestic equities were spanked and suffered
their biggest drop in 6 weeks. As I commented on many occasions, not only does
the global
economy look murky at best, the US is not much better, as this
chart shows.
On the other hand, the pullback was mild compared to the
recent gains, and the bulls may have more to smile about, once the White House
fires the next verbal salvo about how well phase 1 and 2 of the trade deal are
progressing. Wait for it…
ETF Data
updated through Wednesday, November 27, 2019
Methodology/Use of this StatSheet:
1. From the universe of over 1,800 ETFs, I have selected only those with a
trading volume of over $5 million per day (HV ETFs), so that liquidity and a
small bid/ask spread are assured.
2. Trend Tracking Indexes (TTIs)
Buy or Sell decisions for Domestic and International ETFs (section 1 and
2), are made based on the respective TTI and its position either above or below
its long-term M/A (Moving Average). A crossing of the trend line from below
accompanied by some staying power above constitutes a “Buy” signal. Conversely,
a clear break below the line constitutes a “Sell” signal. Additionally, I use a
7.5% trailing stop loss on all positions in these categories to control
downside risk.
3. All other investment arenas do not have a TTI and should be traded
based on the position of the individual
ETF relative to its own respective trend line (%M/A). That’s why those signals
are referred to as a “Selective Buy.” In other words, if an ETF crosses its own
trendline to the upside, a “Buy” signal is generated. Since these areas tend to
be more volatile, I recommend a wider trailing sell stop of 7.5% -10% depending
on your risk tolerance.
If you are unfamiliar with some of the terminology, please see Glossary of Termsand new subscriber information in section 9.
1. DOMESTIC EQUITY ETFs: BUY
— since 02/13/2019
Click on chart to enlarge
Our main directional indicator, the Domestic Trend Tracking Index (TTI-green line in the above chart) is now positioned above its long-term trend line (red) by +6.87% after having generated a new Domestic “Buy” signal effective 2/13/19 as posted.
The markets continued to edge higher with the Dow and
Nasdaq lagging early on but picking up steam mid-session to join the S&P
500 in green territory. Along the path, more records highs were set with positive
economic data providing the necessary ammunition for the gains, which accelerated
into the close.
There was little new information about the ongoing US-China
trade war, so econ data had to carry the weight for this drive higher. We
learned that Q3 GDP was unexpectedly revised up from 1.9% to 2.1% thanks in
part to the Fed’s rate cutting efforts. At the same time, inflation remained
subdued.
Home sales provide a mixed picture with new home sales
being upwardly revised while pending home sales were showing a disappointing
-1.78% MoM drop in October.
It’s I important to realize that over the past few weeks,
since the dip in early October, markets have gone vertical with not even a 0.5%
pullback in the S&P in 35 days. Obviously, the power to blast off like this
came in the form of revving up the Fed’s printing presses (called ‘Not QE’) and
Trump’s relentless tweets and comments of an imminent trade deal, which at this
point does not look like it’s on the horizon. When reviewing the big picture, there
are plenty of concerns that could have easily pulled down markets by 2-3%. But
that did not happen—yet.
Which is why some analysts calling this extreme bullish optimism
a “blow-off top.” This is especially concerning when considering that fundamentals
are in total disconnect with stock market levels. Ed Yardeni’s indicator
makes it all too obvious as to what could happen next.
The markets will be closed on Thanksgiving and are only open
for short session on Friday. I won’t write a weekending report but will post the
StatSheet later today.
I will resume regular posting on Monday. In the meantime,
I wish you a relaxing and enjoyable Thanksgiving weekend.