I
thought that after the drubbing of the past few days, with us getting out of
the market altogether, that a rebound might finally be in order. But no such
luck, as the Dow continued swan diving by being down another 1,000 points
shortly after the opening, but it recovered at the end of the session. Losses were
heavy for the week with the S&P 500 plunging some -11.5%.
Again,
the fact the world may be facing a combination of supply and demand shock seems
to be slowly sinking in and is clearly reflected in this week’s sell-off, as markets
are anticipatory in nature—and in this case are anticipating the worst.
One
analyst explains it in a simplified way:
China
has closed a reported 70,000 movie theatres because of the virus. That’s a
supply shock, and no amount of income (demand) stimulus will boost ticket
sales. Of course, people may increase the number of downloads of films and
games to play at home, as we have seen, but this is nothing more than drops in
the ocean in terms of the overall economy.
Despite
calls for the Fed to cut rates as an emergency measure, officials so far have pushed
back and have remained non-committal. I believe that by next week, we might see
a change of heart with Central Bankers creating coordinated efforts to cut rates
and increase liquidity, all in the hope of putting a floor under this market.
While
this may boost equities on a short-term basis, the Fed can’t print a vaccine to
solve the coronavirus issue, so we’ll be back shortly having to face and deal with
the fallout effects.
To
put this week’s bloodbath into perspective, ZH posted that the Dow saw its fastest
collapse from an all-time peak since 1928, while the S&P 500 suffered its
fastest peak-to-correction plunge ever.
Fed
head Powell made an appearance and spoke in general terms to calm the markets,
which finally created a small rebound
effect. Even if the now anticipated rate cut materializes, the outcome is far from
being certain. ZH summed it up best:
In
other words, if or rather when the corona pandemic gets even worse after
central banks have fired their collective bazooka, the market’s response will
be far more adverse as central banks will have staked their credibility on
being able to offset the economic consequences of the pandemic (they can’t,
unless they can print viral antibodies), while investors will now be looking
into the abyss…
Nobody
knows how this will play, but I am glad we’re watching this movie from the
sidelines.
ETF Data
updated through Thursday, February 27, 2020
Methodology/Use of this StatSheet:
1. From the universe of over 1,800 ETFs, I have selected only those with a
trading volume of over $5 million per day (HV ETFs), so that liquidity and a
small bid/ask spread are assured.
2. Trend Tracking Indexes (TTIs)
Buy or Sell decisions for Domestic and International ETFs (section 1 and
2), are made based on the respective TTI and its position either above or below
its long-term M/A (Moving Average). A crossing of the trend line from below
accompanied by some staying power above constitutes a “Buy” signal. Conversely,
a clear break below the line constitutes a “Sell” signal. Additionally, I use a
7.5% trailing stop loss on all positions in these categories to control
downside risk.
3. All other investment arenas do not have a TTI and should be traded
based on the position of the individual
ETF relative to its own respective trend line (%M/A). That’s why those signals
are referred to as a “Selective Buy.” In other words, if an ETF crosses its own
trendline to the upside, a “Buy” signal is generated. Since these areas tend to
be more volatile, I recommend a wider trailing sell stop of 7.5% -10% depending
on your risk tolerance.
If you are unfamiliar with some of the terminology, please see Glossary of Termsand new subscriber information in section 9.
1. DOMESTIC EQUITY ETFs: SELL
— since 02/27/2020
Click on chart to enlarge
Our main
directional indicator, the Domestic Trend Tracking Index (TTI-green line in the
above chart) is now positioned below its long-term trend line (red) by -4.75%
after having generated a new Domestic “Sell” signal effective 2/27/20 as
posted.
The link
below shows all High Volume (HV) Domestic Equity ETFs. The sorting order is by
M-Index ranking. Prices in all linked tables below are updated through 02/27/2020,
unless otherwise noted. Price data not yet available at publication is
indicated with 00.00% or -100.00%. Please note that distributions are not
included in the current momentum numbers.
Whenever the
TTI is above the trend line, and therefore in “Buy” mode, you can either use
the tables in the link below to make your selections or choose from the 10 ETFs
in the Spotlight, which are featured daily as part of the market commentary:
The
International Trend Tracking Index (green) has now moved -4.58% below its
long-term trend line (red) after having generated a new SSell” signal effective
10/29/2019. It’s been on a wild rollercoaster ride all year, since
international markets showed far more uncertainty and volatility than the US
environment.
The listings
in the link below represent the High Volume (HV) International ETFs I track to
be used during a Buy cycle. They are sorted by M-Index ranking:
This ETF
Master list shows the total of all ETFs listed, which allows you to get a quick
overview of leaders and laggards. The sorting order is by M-Index. Momentum
figures for all ETFs are not adjusted for dividends.
The link below
contains a list of HV ETFs for countries/regions, which I am tracking weekly.
Please note that data in this table does not include adjustments due to
distributions.
Country
funds, especially over the past few years, have been volatile. So, the use of a
trailing stop loss (I use 10%) is imperative to protect your portfolio from
severe downside moves.
5. SECTOR ETFs: SELECTIVE
BUY
To diversify
our portfolios, we always need to look for different opportunities to invest
our money. The table of HV Sector ETF listings in the following link covers a
broad spectrum of possibilities. The sorting order is by M-Index:
Here too, I
recommend the use of a 10% trailing stop loss to minimize the risk.
6. BOND & DIVIDEND ETFs: SELECTIVE BUY
If you
prefer using ETFs for the generation of income, here’s a list of bond and
dividend paying ETFs. It’s important to first look at how these instruments
have held up in terms of momentum figures. Then you should visit your favorite
financial web site to examine yield and other details.
Please note
that data in this table does not include adjustments due to distributions.
Please note
that some of the above funds try to outperform the index they are tied to by
the percentage stated. While this can enhance your returns, it can certainly
accelerate your losses as well. No matter which way you choose, be sure to work
with a trailing sell stop (I suggest 10%) and be aware that volatility will be
your constant companion.
8. NEW SUBSCRIBER INFORMATION
To get a
head start on more successful investing, please click on:
In case you
missed it, you can download my latest e-book “How to beat the S&P 500…with
the S&P 500,” here. If you are
investing your 401k and must use mutual funds, I suggest you primarily stick
with the S&P 500 as described in my book. Of course, you can always use the
above tables to find sector or country ETFs to your liking and use the
equivalent mutual funds as offered by your custodian.
Disclosure:
I
am obliged to inform you that I, as well as my advisory clients, own some of
the ETFs listed in the above table. Furthermore, they do not represent a
specific investment recommendation for you, they merely show which ETFs from
the universe I track are falling within the guidelines specified.
The adage that “sometimes nothing happens in a decade
and sometimes a decade happens in a week” sure rang true, as the coronavirus
induced sell fest continued with utter abandon with downward momentum accelerating.
As I posted yesterday, my planned limited liquidation of broadly
diversified domestic ETFs turned into a “Sell All” early in the session, as the
major indexes continued with their best imitation of a swan dive. Besides some
hedged holdings and gold, we are now in cash watching this debacle unfold from
the sidelines.
As ZH elaborated, in the space of just six days, we went
from a record high to a correction with the Dow
down over 3,000 points or -10.5%). At the same, the eerily familiar comparisons
to the events of 1928-1932 are making the rounds, with this
chart providing the comparison to current market activity.
Then this:
The market is already pricing in at least 3
rate-cuts in 2020 and the odds of March cut are soaring, despite the obvious
fact that The Fed can’t print vaccines to ‘salve’ the supply-chain block and if
lower rates are supposed to spark more consumption, where are you going to
consume? Not at crowded public places like theaters, restaurants, and sports
stadiums?
It’s seems to become more well known that global economies
are facing an unexpected and unprecedented supply chain shock that can’t be fixed
quickly and will leave the Central Banks somewhat powerless, although I expect
the liquidity spigots to be wide open soon.
To add insult to injury was the fact that the widely
followed S&P 500 “lost” it’s 200-day moving average, as this chart
shows. This means that downward momentum could worsen and deepen this newly formed
bear market.
It’s good to be on the sidelines for the time being.
The sudden turnaround in then markets kept me from liquidating
those holdings that had come close to their trailing sell stops. It’s a known
fact that sharp market drops can be followed by violent rebounds, which we saw
early in the session. The only problem was that this move had the smell of a
dead-cat bounce, which is exactly how it turned out.
Still, it was some relief from the selling stampede of the
past few days, but it does not mean the economic effects of the coronavirus have
been nullified. Far from it, as the confirmed cases of infections and deaths outside
of China have continued to spread, there will be a financial hangover for some
time to come.
Those investors that got motivated by buying the dips
over the past few days were, with the benefit of hindsight, much too early and disappointed,
as the dip-buy fest did not turn out well so far. To me, it’s doubtful that a
V-shape type of recovery is possible soon.
In the end, it was only the Nasdaq which managed a green
close with the other 2 major indexes slipping slightly in the red, which was somewhat
disheartening given the early race out of the blocks.
As a result of today’s action, our main directional
indicator, the Domestic Trend Tracking Index (TTI), dropped below its long-term
trend line into bearish territory, although by only a modest -0.62%. That means
that the odds of a bear market facing us have grown considerably.
Since this is the TTIs first dip “below the line,” I will
start reducing our domestic equity exposure and will issue an all-out “Sell”
signal, once the TTI shows some staying power in bear territory.
Again, I will hold off with any corrective measures, should
the major indexes again be in rally mode during tomorrow’s session. However, if
downward momentum accelerates, I will adjust my liquidations accordingly.
For those hoping for a turnaround Tuesday, it did not happen,
as virus headwinds continued to spread around the world. An early rebound
proved to be meaningless with the downward trend remaining intact.
Internationally, it was worse than domestically, with our
International TTI diving below its long-term trend line by a margin large enough
to generate a “Sell” signal for that arena. Please see section 3 for details.
Market sentiment was mixed, as dip buyers try to step in
to prop up the indexes, but volume was not heavy enough to accomplish anything
other than a temporary halt in the downward swing.
After Monday’s drubbing, traders expected a bounce back,
or at least a pause in downward momentum, but the tumble continued unabated. Of
course, investor complacency, caused by the Fed’s support policy of the
markets, has many in shock, as realization set in that markets can go down, and
that corrections of 5-10% are a perfectly normal occurrence.
Not helping the mood were some economic news showing that
the Fed Business Survey crashed in February with new orders collapsing, while
Subprime Credit Card Delinquencies spiked
to record highs and surpassed the financial-crisis peak.
The S&P 500 price of 3,200 was considered by some analysts
a crucial support level and, once broken, could lead to higher volatility and
more downside risk, in the -10% area. Well, the level did not put up any fight,
and the index sliced right through it closing the session at 3,130.
As a result, our Domestic TTI, the main directional indicator,
headed south as well and has now reached a point that is within striking
distance of a “Sell” signal. As you can see in section 3 below, we are
currently only 0.35% away from this event becoming reality.
If it does, and the trendline is clearly pierced to the
downside, we will move out of the markets and to the safety of the sidelines,
as the odds of this turning into a full-blown bear market will have increased.
Fed vice-chair Clarida did not help matters by saying:
US economy and monetary policy are in a good
place, noting that it is still too soon to speculate on whether the coronavirus
will lead to a material change in US economic outlook.
Despite a temporary pause in the drop, while Clarida was
talking, downward momentum picked up again, as it became clear that there were
no solutions or promises forthcoming. Interestingly, the chart
I posted last week, proved to be an accurate prognosticator, as the S&P 500
finally caught down to global liquidity.
In my advisor practice, we will start liquidating some of
those positions, whose trailing sell stops were triggered, and will prepare for
an all-out domestic “Sell” signal.
World markets joined in unison by selling off with weekend
news about the coronavirus continuing worries that global economies will not
escape unscathed and take a hit of unknown proportions.
Sure, news media and markets tend to overreact, but the negative
virus effects can’t be denied, as the struggle with containment policies and massive
unknowns seem to get worse.
It’s no surprise that markets are feeling nervous this
morning, given the known facts, which analyst Bill Blain summarized as follows:
The economic damage in terms of cancelled
tourist trips to Asia and vice-versa, empty container ships, global supply
chain breakdown shuttering factories across the globe, commodities tumbling, raising
fears of mass defaults as just-in-time manufacturers fail to make interest
payments is clear.
He went on to elaborate:
This crisis comes at the top of massive
bubbles in stocks and bonds, fueled by 10-years of accommodative monetary
experimentation – just at a time when the global monetary authorities are
increasingly understanding the urgent need undo the unintended negative
consequences, end QE, to normalize interest rates and take the pressure out of
asset bubbles.
Forget about normalizing interest rates, it will be the
opposite with bond yields crashing
this morning, as the 10-year dropped some 10 basis points to below 1.40%. Considering
the above, I believe the Central Banks will go all out and provide further “accommodative”
policy support meaning yields will be heading towards the zero bound, as is the
case in many developed countries.
As ZH points out in the above chart, a break below this “tipping
point,” increases the probability to more than 50% of the Fed cutting back rates
to 0%.
Along those lines, we may very well witness a well-known
mantra come into play, set in motion by former ECB president Draghi, for the
Fed to do “whatever it takes” to avoid an economic breakdown.
In the end, for us trend trackers, the only things that matter
are: Is the major trend is still intact and/or have any sell stops been
triggered?
For right now, the answer to both is no (see section 3
below), so we will continue to hold until either one of these two conditions come
into play.
Despite today’s snapping of complacency, it’s also noteworthy
that the S&P 500 closed today at the same price it had when the month of
February started and remains within 5% of its all-time highs.