Here are this past week’s top 5 winners and losers from my High Volume ETF Master List:
Metals and Natural Resources took top billing last week, and the more conservative, but high ranking ETFs XLV and XLP, gave back some of their gains. Turkey still remains one of the more volatile plays in the country ETF arena.
This was the question on reader Daniel’s mind as he emailed the following:
I am retired and looking for a “reliable & safe” dividend paying ETFs for income.
Three ETFs that I have looked at are:
1. SDY – Tracks HY Div Aristocrats Index 2. VIG – tracks Mergect Div Achievers Index 3. DVY – tracks DJ Select Div Index 4. Others?
What is your recommendation?
Let’s first hone in on the word ‘reliable’ on Daniel’s wish list. I assume that he means reliable in terms of providing a regular income stream. If you look at the dividend histories of SDY, VIG and DVY, you can see that they indeed paid their dividends on a regular basis.
The more difficult determination to evaluate is whether any of these ETFs are ‘safe.’ Daniel was very vague, so here again I have to assume that he refers to price stability. The short answer is sometimes prices are stable and sometimes they are not and plunge.
Let’s take a look at a five year chart (courtesy of YahooFinance) of Daniel’s ETF selections:
ETF/No Load Fund Tracker StatSheet
————————————————————-
THE LINK TO OUR CURRENT ETF/MUTUAL FUND STATSHEET IS:
————————————————————
Market Commentary
Friday, May 27, 2011
AGAINST THE WIND
It was a repeat performance of the prior week, as the markets started out to the downside on Monday and spent the last four trading days trying to climb back. In the case of the S&P 500, it was aimless meandering within a narrow trading range as the index ended up giving back 2 points.
The entire month, the major indexes have been tiptoeing on a balance beam, and it appeared that at anytime the downside could come into play big time. It did not happen yet, but even Dr. Doom, Nouriel Roubini, chimed in with a similar tune in “Stocks teetering on ‘tipping point’ of correction.”
ETF/Mutual Fund Data updated through Thursday, May 26, 2011
If you are not familiar with some of the terminology used, please see the Glossary of Terms.
1. DOMESTIC EQUITY MUTUAL FUNDS/ETFs: BUY— since 6/3/2009
As announced via a blog post, on 6/2/2009, the TTI triggered a buy signal with an effective date of 6/3/2009. We will use the 7% trailing stop loss of our positions as an exit point or the crossing of the trend line to the downside, whichever occurs first.
As of today, our Trend Tracking Index (TTI—green line in above chart) has broken above its long term trend line (red) by +4.62%.
This past week’s pullback in the markets clearly affected the High Volume ETFs as well. To clarify, High Volume (HV) ETFs are defined as those with an average daily volume of $10 million or higher.
These ETFs are generated from my selected list of 90 that I use in my advisor practice. It cuts out the “noise,” which simply means it eliminates those ETFs that I would never buy because of their volume limitations.
When markets correct, you can easily spot the results around the cutline (trend line), especially with those ETFs that have marginal momentum figures to begin with. They are the first ones to succumb to bearish forces. As a result, downward momentum pushed some ETFs below the yellow line and others deeper into bear market territory.
Here are some of the more dramatic moves:
Singapore (EWS) from +20 to +9
Spain (EWP) from +18 to +6
Emerging Markets (VWO) from +12 to +4
Slipping below the line were the following:
South Africa (EZA) from +8 to -1
China (FXI) from +4 to -2
Russia (RSX) from +3 to -3
If you look at the table, you’ll notice that currently only 1 equity ETF offers a buying opportunity, because of its positive momentum numbers all the way across and a low DrawDown (DD% column):
In another repeat performance, the market pullback continued during the past week and affected all of our portfolios.
There were a few surprises. Our Trend Tracking Portfolio (#1) not only held up the best, it actually gained in the face of the selloff. This was followed closely by a lesser gain of the Aggressive Portfolio (#3), which now holds the 2nd place on a YTD basis. The largest loss occurred in the income portfolio (#5) which, however, is still hanging on to the #1 position.
No trailing sell stops were triggered, although 2 positions (EPP and VEU) briefly dropped below their respective trigger points on Tuesday, but closed back above as of today.
When markets sell off, as they have been for the past few weeks, you need to observe the effect on the various portfolios, in order to evaluate which one you are most comfortable with. It’s easy to like a well performing portfolio in a bull market, but can you live with it when the bear rears its ugly head?