This was the question on reader Daniel’s mind as he emailed the following:
I am retired and looking for a “reliable & safe” dividend paying ETFs for income.
Three ETFs that I have looked at are:
1. SDY – Tracks HY Div Aristocrats Index 2. VIG – tracks Mergect Div Achievers Index 3. DVY – tracks DJ Select Div Index 4. Others?
What is your recommendation?
Let’s first hone in on the word ‘reliable’ on Daniel’s wish list. I assume that he means reliable in terms of providing a regular income stream. If you look at the dividend histories of SDY, VIG and DVY, you can see that they indeed paid their dividends on a regular basis.
The more difficult determination to evaluate is whether any of these ETFs are ‘safe.’ Daniel was very vague, so here again I have to assume that he refers to price stability. The short answer is sometimes prices are stable and sometimes they are not and plunge.
Let’s take a look at a five year chart (courtesy of YahooFinance) of Daniel’s ETF selections:


