Digging Into More Sell Stop Details

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

One reader had this question about the use of sell stops:

I already own some funds where the most recent high was about 30 days ago and the funds have come down about 2.5 to 4%. If I want to use the 7% trailing stop rule, do I simply take 7% of the high 30 days ago and set that as the stop?

And if I buy a fund now, do I still use the most recent high from 30 days ago or just from the price I just purchased the fund? Thank you for you newsletter and blog.

The base price from which you measure your sell stops is in fact the highest price this fund has reached since you bought it. In your first example, that would be the price from 30 days ago.

However, if you decide to purchase more of this fund now at a lower price, you start all over in terms of finding a new high price for this portion of your holdings. For example, if you buy this fund now at $10 and the price subsequently ends up moving something like 9.90, 10.05, 10.20, 10.40, 10.30, 10.15, etc., then 10.40 would be your new high price to be used as a base for figuring your 7% sell stop (until it is replaced by a new high, of course).

I have never come across this situation, since my preference is to add more positions on the way up, when momentum is in my favor, and not on the way down, when a trend reversal could be in the making. This keeps the same high price high price intact for old and new positions.

Sunday Musings: When Less Is More

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Occasionally, I have written about the lack of investment choices in 401k plans.

While I manage a number of these, most are with Fidelity and have a wide variety of fund selections although many still have no access to ETFs.

Even though ETFs are all the rage, are you really disadvantaged by not having them available?

To offer a different viewpoint, let me share with you this experience about a client who works for a Fortune 500 company.

When I first took over his 401k account 5 years ago, I was simply flabbergasted when I saw the investment choices. Given the type of company he was employed by, I expected to see, well, a wide variety fund selection covering all of the major markets.

When I logged on to his account, I was downright shocked. The entire 401k plan consisted of the following:

1. Short-Term Fixed Income Fund
2. Growth Equity Fund
3. International Stock Fund
4. The Company’s own common stock

That was it. Additionally, the growth and international selections were not modeled after some well-known mutual fund, but unidentifiable as far as looking at long-term historical trends was concerned.

To me, this was about as skinny as you can get when it comes to fund choices.

Here’s the surprising outcome.

When our international TTI signaled a Buy on 5/11/09, I decided to use my incremental buying procedure by allocating 1/3 of this portfolio to the International Stock Fund. The fund rallied nicely and, 3 weeks later, it had gained over 5%, so I allocated another 1/3 increment. Subsequently, the domestic TTI signaled a Buy and I invested the remaining 1/3 into the Growth Equity Fund on 6/3/09.

The markets bobbed and weaved, especially in July, but the international fund holding never pulled off its high enough to generate a whip-saw signal. Neither did the Growth Equity fund.

As a result, this portfolio has grown over 20% (for the period 5/11/09-11/13/09), matching the S&P; 500, despite the incremental buying process. While the sell stops were in place at all times, we only got as close as -5% at one point.

Here’s a portfolio that had nothing going in terms of investment options, yet it outperformed (much to my chagrin) all others, which had more investment choices in mutual funds, ETFs, sectors and countries.

This is clearly a case when less can be more, certainly in terms of results. It underscores the point I have made before that less volatile funds/ETFs have advantages when used with trend tracking, because they tend to avoid whip-saw signals.

With the intention of the investment world not only being focused on ETFs but also on providing a mind numbing number of choices, it may behoove some investors to review the sometimes casino like behavior that this can promote.

Scale back on volatility and look for a few steady performers because, as in this case, slow and steady has a good chance of winning the race.

Two Types Of Whip-Saw Signals

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Reader VR posted these comments:

I understand there are two ways you can get whip-sawed. One is the big bang event in which the trend line crosses from buy-to-sell-to-buy.

The other and more frequent one within the buy cycle is if your fund drops more than a certain percentage points stopping you out and then going back up through the old high prompting you to get back into the market.

Can you give us an insight into any analysis you may have done to tell us whether it is beneficial to follow only the larger cycles or to follow the more frequent cycles within the ‘buy’ zone?

In other words, is it better to just follow the trend line?

The short and incomplete answer would be: It depends on market behavior.

If you have a slow and steady uptrend, with the Trend Tracking Indexes (TTIs) remaining fairly close to their trend lines, then you could use the trend line as your exit point. Actually, that’s what I have done throughout the late 80, 90s and into the year 2000.

Things changed when the tech bubble burst and the markets not only crashed but also whip-sawed several times during the first nine months of 2000. Take a look at a chart of the domestic TTI for that period:



The large red arrows on the left show the highs and lows the domestic TTI made during the blow-off period. It is obvious that, if you had followed the piercing of the trend line as a signal to sell, you would have given back most of your accumulated profits since the Buy of 11/17/1999.

That is the inherent problem. Whether you use the TTIs as I do, or simple 200-day moving averages for individual funds/ETFs, the issue remains the same.

A strong bullish period will drive the price line (green) way above trend line (red). If this happens within a short period of time (6 months or less), the trend line lags too much to lock in any profits in the event of a trend reversal. While you may avoid an above the trend line whip-saw here and there, you also risk giving back most of your gains.

That creates an emotional problem for investors as well when seeing accumulated profits evaporate by waiting for the trend line piercing to generate the sell. I have seen, during violent moves such as the above chart shows, unrealized gains of 40% evaporate down to 3%. While you personally maybe be able to handle that, if you manage money for others, that is simply not acceptable.

The bottom line is that I have found the use of a trailing sell stop, when above the trend line, a far better choice in controlling risk (locking in profits and limiting losses), especially in the volatile environment we are living in.

No Load Fund/ETF Tracker updated through 11/12/2009

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

My latest No Load Fund/ETF Tracker has been posted at:

http://www.successful-investment.com/newsletter-archive.php

Continued bullishness has the S&P; 500 knocking on its 1,100 level.

Our Trend Tracking Index (TTI) for domestic funds/ETFs has now crossed its trend line (red) to the upside by +8.45% keeping the current buy signal intact. The effective date was June 3, 2009.



The international index has now broken above its long-term trend line by +13.21%. A Buy signal was triggered effective May 11, 2009. We are holding our positions subject to a trailing stop loss.



[Click on charts to enlarge]

For more details, and the latest market commentary, as well as the updated No load Fund/ETF StatSheet, please see the above link.

Deploying “Stopped Out” Money

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

The use of sell stops and re-investing monies you have been stopped out of as the market resumes its upward trend, has been the hot topic of the past few weeks. Reader Paul had this to add:

A few questions regarding your tactics for reentering the market with “stopped out” money:

1. Typically, what kicks off your decision to start reentering the market?
2. Do you only enter into funds that have a 0.0 %DD?
3. Assuming the trend remains positive, do you give yourself a target deadline for reinvesting all of your “stopped out” money?

For one, a resumption of upward momentum will always make me realize that I have been whip-sawed and cause me to re-deploy the proceeds such as happened early this week.

Second, depending on your risk aversion, you could wait until the funds/ETFs, you’ve been stopped out of, take out their old highs before re-entering. Or, you could select different funds/ETFs along the lines as I profiled back in July in “Using The Benefit Of Hindsight.”

Third, I don’t give myself a deadline for re-investing stopped out money but, if I see a rally building early in the morning, such as we had last Monday, I try to get back in as quickly as I can.

Keep in mind that trying to find a new entry point is not an exact science. You never know for sure if you’re making the right move at the right time. The idea is to get back onboard quickly if the trend goes your way. This also means that you need to quickly accept the fact that the stop point may have turned into a whip-saw by not dwelling on it.

That’s the moment in time to look at the big picture and remember that you are using stop losses for a reason, which is to limit downside risk.

An Emerging-Markets Bubble?

Ulli Uncategorized Contact



The WSJ featured an interesting viewpoint in “Are ETFs Causing an Emerging-Markets Bubble?” Here are a few highlights:

U.S. investors have pumped roughly $26 billion into emerging-markets funds so far this year. Of that, $15 billion came in through exchange-traded funds — portfolios that hold every stock in a market benchmark with utterly no regard to price.

Several hedge-fund managers and other active stockpickers have told me that this “mindless money” is distorting valuations and pumping up a potentially monstrous bubble.

At first blush, it is hard to imagine that they are wrong. As money pours into the ETFs, they must mechanically match their holdings to those in the emerging-market indexes. That forced buying drives up stock prices, attracting still more new money into the ETFs, spiraling stock prices even higher.

Even Gus Sauter, chief investment officer at Vanguard Group, one of the world’s largest managers of index funds and ETFs, is concerned. “Obviously it’s the last trade that determines the price of everything,” he says, “and there have been large flows [from ETFs into emerging markets], perhaps leading to a bit of a bubble.”

Mr. Sauter adds that several markets, such as Brazil and Peru, are up roughly 100% in 2009. “Either something has changed quite dramatically,” he deadpans, “or pricing has been dislocated from reality. And it’s probably a little bit of the latter.”
…

Thanks to obscure provisions of the U.S. Internal Revenue Code and the Investment Company Act of 1940, which governs how mutual funds are organized, ETFs can’t allow their assets to become over-concentrated in a handful of holdings. In general, they can’t keep more than 25% of their money in a single stock, and at least half of their assets must be in securities that each account for no more than 5% of total holdings.

Now that emerging markets have risen so far so fast, these tax requirements may compel some large ETFs to begin selling their biggest holdings. Ms. Ting says that her fund automatically sells some of its Petrobras holdings, currently 23% of assets, whenever they near the 25% threshold. They are replaced, she says, with “securities with similar risk factors.”
…

So what does all this mean for investors? ETFs probably haven’t caused a bubble, and they might even help a bit to prevent one from forming. But many will remain superconcentrated bets on very risky markets. If you invest in an ETF with most of its assets in a few stocks and think you have made a diversified bet, the real bubble is the one between your own ears.

As a general rule, I don’t think bubbles in any market pop over night. Sure, you may have the occasional Black Swan event, but even during last year’s market crash, prices started to head lower at a slow pace at first and accelerated later on.

Take a look at the EEM chart above. For those with sell stops in place, the initial market pullback provided plenty of opportunity to liquidate any positions. Even if you gave yourself more room and sold as the price crossed the trend line to the downside, you would have had no problem getting out.

As always, the key here is not to worry about wild speculations as to what might or might not happen to this market but to be prepared to exit when the trends reverse.

That alertness to changing conditions, more than anything else, will save your portfolio from a receiving a severe haircut and will help you emotionally to better deal with a declining market.

Disclosure: We currently have no positions in EEM.