Honing In On Bond Funds And Sell Stops

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Using sell stops with dividend paying bond funds works the same as with any other equity mutual fund/ETF. Reader Joe had this to say:

My question today deals with setting stops on junk bond and short term bond funds.

A large element of their performance is their dividend, which may be 6 or 7%. How do you account for dividends in setting stops on these types of funds?

For example, if the highest price in the period I’ve held the fund is $10.00, with a 7% stop, it looks like I should sell the fund when it hits 9.30. However, with the dividends going to purchase additional shares, in dollar terms I may be “down” only 4.5 or 5% with the price at 9.30.

Any thoughts on this?

As I mentioned before, whenever a fund/ETF distribution occurs, you need to reduce the high price of your sell stop by the amount of the dividend. As in your example, if your high price is $10.00, and a divided of, say, 0.11 is paid, your new high price becomes 9.89 from which to calculate the 7% trailing stop loss point.

That is not only important for dividend paying bond funds, but also for equity funds, which will all declare their yearend distributions within the next 30 days. To be accurate with your trailing sell stops, you need to reduce your high price by this amount, no matter whether it consists of dividends or capital gains.

No Load Fund/ETF Tracker updated through 11/25/2009

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

My latest No Load Fund/ETF Tracker has been posted at:

http://www.successful-investment.com/newsletter-archive.php

Today’s sell off caused by the Dubai debt debacle left the major indexes unchanged for the week.

Our Trend Tracking Index (TTI) for domestic funds/ETFs has now crossed its trend line (red) to the upside by +8.35% keeping the current buy signal intact. The effective date was June 3, 2009.



The international index has now broken above its long-term trend line by +11.14%. A Buy signal was triggered effective May 11, 2009. We are holding our positions subject to a trailing stop loss.

[Click on charts to enlarge]
For more details, and the latest market commentary, as well as the updated No load Fund/ETF StatSheet, please see the above link.

Happy Thanksgiving

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Hat tip to Mish at Global Economics for pointing to “Geography Of A Recession.” It’s an interactive chart, which displays the changes in unemployment rates by month and county from January 2007 to September 2009. Fascinating and depressing at the same time…

Thanksgiving in our family will be on the quiet side this year, which I don’t mind at all. I’ll get in a couple hours of work early in the morning and, since I could not get a tennis game set up, will go through my alternative exercise routine.

Since the weather forecast in Southern California calls for a balmy day in the mid 70s, my wife and I will head for the beach for a lunch picnic and a lot of reading. With our 13-year old son joining us (if he can interrupt his surfing), it promises to be a nice relaxing day.

We will have turkey dinner in the early evening at a restaurant overlooking the ocean at the Huntington Beach pier to close out a day of stress free R&R.;

Happy Thanksgiving to you and your family!

Will The Real Trend Line Please Stand Up?

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Our buy and sell signals are based on our Trend Tracking Indexes (TTIs) crossing their respective trend lines (39-week Simple Moving Average). Reader VR posed an interesting thought about it:

Thanks for your response to my question about trend tracking on Saturday (11/16). I understand no strategy works all the time and so you have adapted to more volatile reality of the market in the last few years. I have a related question.

By buying and selling more frequently, are we not following a shorter MA trend line without putting that in words? For example, what we end up doing is more or less selling with a 7% trailing stop on a 50 Day MA instead of 200 Day MA of our published trend line.

In general, we want our new invisible ‘trading’ trend line to follow the chart steepness of a particular security as closely as possible while we still have our long term ‘zoning’ trend line of 200 Day MA as our guide.

The idea is not to buy and sell more often. Our buy signals are generated based on the Trend Tracking Indexes (TTIs) crossing their long-term trend line (39 week SMA). To me, that would be quite different from buying and selling based on a 50-day moving average trend line, which would definitely increase the frequency of your signals.

While the trailing sell stop is based on a fixed percentage, I don’t think that really shortens the trend line we’re following. The idea is to simply control downside risk as much as we can without waiting for the TTI to pierce its actual 39-week MA.

As I posted before, waiting for the long-term trend line to be pierced to the downside will only work to your advantage if your price line is within close proximity of the trend line. If it’s not (right now it’s +8.83% above it), and you wait for it to happen, you are guaranteed to turn a potential profit into a loss, since the TTI drops at a much slower rate than the price of the security your tracking.

If it seems to you that we are following a new “invisible trading trend line,” that’s fine, as long as you follow its signals and protect your portfolio when this rally comes to an end.

Learning From Past Mistakes

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

I have had some interesting email exchanges with reader Tad, who was kind enough to share some of his experiences:

Yeah, I understand, “analysis paralysis” we used to say. I am a math nut, what can I say…. sorry…. I have managed my own money since 1984 and had done extremely well, until last year. Can’t do anything about the past, except learn from it.

As to your clarification request. Basically, please correct me if I am wrong, if you have over $500,000, which I do (if I would have been following you instead of Bob Brinker and Ken Heebner), I would have at least 3 times what I do now, but I have seen the light, I hope… you advise to pick 5 to 8 broadly diversified funds, your first buy should be 1/3 of a fund, if it goes up 5% (buy percent), if the trend continues the next day, buy the next third, if that goes up another 5%, if the trend continues the next day, buy the final third.

If readers do that and then decide to arbitrarily increase the sell stops, due primarily to higher betas, they are taking on more risk of losing money in those buys. Ergo, to offset that risk, you could increase the 5% above to correlate more with ones increased sell stop. Please see my attached plan. It has evolved and I have made some mistakes, but I am a newbie to your system, and always trying to learn and improve my returns.

I strongly believe that eventually all sell stops will hit and I will be in cash again and when I start buying again, I want to have improved. If you have already gone down this path, please let me know. Constantly trying to do better.

Let me clarify a few items. The incremental buying procedure (1/3 at a time) does not depend on the amount of money you have to invest. To me, it is strictly a reflection of the risk tolerance of an individual.

For example, if you are the aggressive type you can, at the beginning of a buy cycle, allocate 100% of your portfolio. The downside is that, if the market goes against you right away, you lose about 7% using the trailing sell stop discipline.

If that potential loss does not sit well with you, invest only 50%, which reduces the risk to about 3.5% of portfolio. Or, if you are the conservative type, use the incremental buying procedure by starting out with only 33% portfolio exposure, which reduces your potential loss to about 2.5%. That’s how you should determine the amount of money you are willing to allocate once a buy is triggered.

No matter where you fit in, you can further reduce risk by using lower beta funds/ETFs, which will move less than the overall market as measured by the S&P; 500. While this will limit upside potential, it will also reduce possible whip-saws when the markets correct.

All these decisions are not a matter of right or wrong but merely one of preference depending on your risk appetite.

And last not least, eventually all sell stops will get triggered and therefore guarantee a move back to money market.

The longer it takes to get there while the trend is up, the more profits will have accumulated. In that case, the sell stop will no longer function as a measure to limit your losses but to lock in your profits. And that’s a good thing.

Trend Tracking And Dollar Cost Averaging (DCA)

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

One reader had these thoughts to see if he could combine DCA with trend tracking:

What are your thoughts on dollar cost averaging (DCA)? The traditional concept, such as contributing to an IRA monthly or quarterly, or regularly to a 401K at work, is a good way to save/invest. To get the most benefit of DCA, the most volatile fund should be used, to buy more shares on the downswings. (A fund with no volatility, such as a money market, looses this advantage.)

However, how should this be managed with sell stops and TTI trend exits? The DCA concept is to keep investing through market downturns.

How should DCA be incorporated into your plan?

I’ve never been a friend of dollar cost averaging since the issues I have with it are not much different than those with buy-and-hold.

To be clear, I use a form of dollar cost averaging after the markets have generated a buy signal to move into equities via my incremental buying process. So I try to average in on the way up (not on the way down), when momentum supports my decision.

Take a look back at 2008. Using DCA, you would have purchased incrementally more shares as asset prices declined. These purchases at lower prices will show some gains during this recent rally. However, the bulk of your assets, which you had accumulated prior to the crash, took a big hit.

DCA may get you in the market at lower prices from time to time, but it will not prevent your portfolio from getting slaughtered during a major market decline. If you have incremental money to invest, do so during bullish periods only and track your sell stops as recommended.