Sunday Musings: Who Do You Listen To?

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

As the New Year gets underway, the media will be out in full force again trying to predict as to what the stock market will do in 2010 as well as the direction the economy will be taking.

My view has always been to pay attention to the few who saw the current credit/real estate crisis coming and not those who were clueless but now all of a sudden seem to have gained such insight that they feel qualified to tell us what the future will hold.

Mish at Global Economics recently featured an interview done by Barron’s with two hedge fund managers who anticipated the crisis and planned accordingly. It’s a worthwhile read:

PERHAPS ONE OF THE greatest failings in the run-up to the financial meltdown was a lack of perspective — an inability by many market participants to see the big picture. Not so with Kevin Duffy and Bill Laggner, principals of the Dallas-based hedge fund Bearing Asset Management. With the help of their proprietary credit-bubble index, developed in 2004, the managers sounded early warnings on housing and credit excesses, and capitalized handsomely on their forecasts by shorting Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac, money-center banks and brokers, builders, mortgage insurers and the like.

Students of the Austrian school of economics, which espouses a free-market philosophy that ascribes business-cycle booms and busts to government meddling with interest rates, the pair is solidly in the contrarian camp, believing that the worst for the markets may be yet to come.

Barron’s: You’ve said that perhaps the most redeeming feature of capitalism is failure. Please explain.

Duffy: Any healthy system needs a way to correct error and remove waste. Nature has extinction, the economy has loss, bankruptcy, liquidation. Interfering in this process lengthens feedback loops. Error and waste are allowed to accumulate, and you ultimately get a massive collapse.

Capitalism is primarily attacked by two groups: utopians who wish to impose a more “compassionate” system, and political capitalists who want to enjoy the fruits of success without bearing the pain of failure. They use the coercion of the state to gain privileges, at the expense of everyone else.

As a country we’ve become less tolerant of economic failure. The result has been a series of interventions, such as meddling in the credit markets, promoting homeownership and creating a variety of safety nets for investors. Each crisis leads to an even greater crisis. The solution is always greater doses of intervention. So the system becomes increasingly unstable. The interventionists never see the bust coming, then blame it on “capitalism.”

Barron’s: What would you have done differently as the credit bubble was bursting and the Fed and the Treasury were declaring that the world would come to an end without an $800 billion bailout package?

Duffy: Allow those who essentially bet wrongly to fail, instead of bailing out people with friends in high places.

Barron’s: What about the argument that a financial panic would have ensued and crushed the little guy?

Duffy: The little guy actually has been crushed. The little guy is always going to be the last one in the soup line. So he will get a bone tossed to him, like cash for clunkers. But if you are Goldman Sachs or if you have got essentially the red bat-phone to Washington, D.C., you are first in line.

Laggner: There is still a multi-trillion dollar shadow banking system that FASB [the Financial Accounting Standards Board] wants to address next year. The central planners have already spent $3.15 trillion on various bailouts, credit backstops, guarantees, etc., and given approximately $17.5 trillion of government commitments, etc., while allowing many of these institutions to remain in place, with the same people running them.

Barron’s: What else could have been done?

Laggner: We could have isolated the money centers and put them in temporary receivership. Then, we could have created — with a mere $100 billion — a thousand community banks. If you believe in fractional reserve lending [in which banks lend multiples of their deposits], something we don’t support, they could have created a trillion dollars in new credit that would have flowed to small and medium-sized businesses. Those are the parts of the economy that are choking.

Barron’s: What kind of financial reform would you like to see?

Laggner: We don’t believe in a central bank. The idea that banks can speculate with essentially free money from the [Federal Reserve], which ultimately is the taxpayer, and that when they lose money the Fed bails them out and then passes that invoice to the taxpayer — that whole model is broken and needs to go away.

Duffy: To get to the heart of the problem, we need to address fractional-reserve banking, which is causing the instability. We have essentially socialized deposit insurance and prevented the bank run, which used to impose discipline on this unstable system. At least it had some check on those who were acting most recklessly. Until we address the root of the problem, we are going to have a series of crises, greater responses and intervention, and more bubbles — and the system will keep perpetuating itself.

Well said. I have always voiced my opinion against bailouts believing that any business that makes the wrong choices should be allowed to fail. Propping up zombie institutions simply means kicking the can down the road by avoiding having to make hard decisions right now and letting it be someone else’s problem in the future.

While you and I have no control over the decisions that have been and will be made, increased instability of the system, as the article mentioned, will sooner or later affect the stock market negatively. Those who are blinded to these facts will eventually repeat the mistakes made in 2008.

It is my firm belief that we are living in an environment where anything can happen with the possibility of a Black Swan event always lurking around the corner. Protect your assets via the use of a trailing sell stop and get away from the silly notion that an investment can be bought and held forever.

You can thank me later.

Reader Q&A: Entering The Market

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Reader Trevor is located in the UK and is looking for a way to enter the market after the run up of last year. Here’s what he had to say:

Although I have read your column avidly for a good while, I did not buy on the last buy signal. (I am in the UK so the funds etc are not directly equivalent). I have a 401k equivalent which buys a number of ETF’s on a monthly basis at low trade costs. BUT I also have a separate online broker account that I can use.

So accepting that none of us can predict the future but based on current momentum are you still investing new money for clients?

If I was starting at this point (slowly following the 1/3 then the second 1/3 after 5% uplift rule with a strict 7% Sell discipline), would I be best to look at ETFs with positive M-Index (not the highest), BUT with positive scores in 4, 8, 12, YTD.

Does it matter that DD% is negative in this choice or is it best to chose funds/ETFs at their current highs (0.00%)?

First, my mode of operation is to evaluate the risk profile of a client (or you should evaluate your own) as discussed in “New Money.”

Second, I do look at the M-Index first along with the %DD to see how a fund/ETF is doing compared to others. Sure, a %DD of 0.00 is something I like to see, because it means the fund is making new highs and upward momentum is still present. Right now, primarily bond funds fall into that category.

As far as equity funds are concerned, even a pull back of up to 2% in the %DD column is acceptable to me. For example, one of the ETFs we’ve owned since June 2009 is QQQQ, and it has only come off its high by -1.02% and never dropped more than -6.55% for the past 6 months.

Third, I look at the individual momentum figures, but my main focus will be on the 4wk number. I do not want to see anything negative there as it represents the most recent past. In the case of QQQQ, the 4wk number is at +4.24%.

Keep in mind that this is not an exact science; I merely try to ascertain that upward momentum has not reversed too much by looking at these numbers.

More importantly, whichever fund/ETF I end up selecting, I know that my downside is limited because of my trailing stop loss discipline. That’s what lets me sleep at night.

No Load Fund/ETF Tracker updated through 12/31/2009

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

My latest No Load Fund/ETF Tracker has been posted at:

http://www.successful-investment.com/newsletter-archive.php

Low volume was prevalent during this final week of the year, so a last minute sell-off was not too surprising.

Our Trend Tracking Index (TTI) for domestic funds/ETFs has now crossed its trend line (red) to the upside by +5.50% keeping the current buy signal intact. The effective date was June 3, 2009.



The international index has now broken above its long-term trend line by +8.76%. A Buy signal was triggered effective May 11, 2009. We are holding our positions subject to a trailing stop loss.

[Click on charts to enlarge]
For more details, and the latest market commentary, as well as the updated No load Fund/ETF StatSheet, please see the above link.

Hedge Clarification—For One Reader

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

One reader has been trying to repeatedly post some rude commentary to this blog. Of course, as is the case with spam attempts and nasty comments, they don’t get published; they go directly where they belong—in the trash can.

Since this will be the last post for 2009, I want to clean the table and address the issue.

The reader was questioning as to why I don’t implement a sell stop strategy for a hedge and, in not doing so, accumulate thousands of dollars in losses. Obviously, that is not the case, so a clarification is in order.

As I wrote in my e-book “The SimpleHedge Strategy,” in order to evaluate a hedge, it needs to be set up on a matrix to properly evaluate it. Here’s one, which I initiated when the markets were in dire straits back on March 2, 2009:


Click on graph to enlarge]

In this case, the hedge consists of a short component and two long components. The idea is that the short component will lose in value if the market rallies, while the long components gain, hopefully at a larger rate than the losses on the short side; and vice versa.

This is exactly what happened. During the study period shown (bull market), the short side lost -40.85% while the long sides gained +89.29% and +64.32% respectively. The net result was a gain of +12.82%

So, how does a sell stop work within these parameters? Very simple. A sell stop in a hedge applies to the performance of the “entire” hedge and not just to one of its components.

The entire hedge never dipped into negative territory, let alone came close to the usual 7% sell stop, as you can see by the red arrow. It only reached a low point of +0.24% on 3/30/09.

The reader apparently had an issue with the short position losing 40.85% and thought it should have been sold the moment a 7% drop had occurred. That’s not the idea of hedging, because the moment you do that you are outright long.

With the benefit of hindsight, that would have been a good move. However, at issue is not whether to be long or short but how do use a sell stop when a hedge strategy is implemented.

To this reader, I suggest to adopt a more courteous tone of voice in 2010, if he ever wants to receive constructive feedback.

Unlucky Seven

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

The market was working on its 7th straight day of gains, when a last hour sell-off pulled the indexes from achieving this feat.

Consecutive gains of more than 5 days in a row are rare indeed and are usually followed by at least one down day. Of course volume was low during this quiet Holiday shortened week so one cannot put too much meaning into the directional activity of the last three trading days of the year.

Economic reports were mixed as consumer confidence showed a slight improvement while a report on home prices was not as robust as hoped for.

I expect the market to meander for the next couple of days before this year comes to an end. While we have all sell stops in place, I don’t think any will be triggered during the remainder of 2009.

More On Dividends And Sell Stops

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Reader Trevor wants to clarify the adjustments that have to be made to the basis for calculating the sell stop when dividends are a being paid:

I am a bit confused about the treatment of dividends having read your recent posts.

I have set up a spreadsheet as you suggested using Yahoo and downloading each day – one column is the High which I amend manually if a new high is achieved since I bought.

If I understand right, it is from this number I deduct the dividend payment. So if the high was a 100.00 and the dividend payment 1.00 then the stop loss would be calculated as 7% off the post dividend high of 99.00. So far so good.

What happens if the market keeps rising (as it seems to be at the moment) and a new high of 101 is achieved? Here I assume that the stop loss now moves to 7% off 101 so negating the impact of the dividend payment?

You are absolutely right. Distributions from dividends and/or capital gains and market activity are two separate things.

In your example, the high price of $100 was correctly reduced by the amount of the dividend of $1 making the new high price $99, from which you now calculate your 7% sell stop. If market activity pushed prices higher, then the highest closing price above $99 becomes your new basis for calculating your stop.

As you pointed out, if prices make a high of $101, then that number serves as the new high point from which you calculate the 7% level, which in this case would be $94 (rounded off).