Clawing Back

Ulli Uncategorized Contact



The last three trading days provided a lot of market excitement but no clear direction. Friday, the major indexes closed down sharply, Tuesday they closed up sharply, and Wednesday all of Tuesday’s gains and then some evaporated again.

It could have been a lot worse had it not been for some serious clawing back starting at half time. One of the culprits causing this pullback after Tuesday’s euphoric rally was China as it was reported that banks were asked to stop issuing new loans for the remainder of this month due to not meeting regulatory capital requirements.

IBM contributed some 29 points for the loss on the Dow as some investors simply had hoped for even better results. Sometimes, better than expected first quarter numbers are just not satisfactory.

One of the few bright spots was the dollar, which rallied sharply. This supports my long-held view that whenever worldwide uncertainty appears, the favorite whipping boy, the U.S dollar, is the beneficiary. I see no reason why that should not continue.

While the direction of the long-term trend remains intact, short-term we may be facing more rough patches, and it remains to be seen as to whether the path of least resistance will be to the downside.

ETFs And 401ks

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

The WSJ reports that “ETFs Make Inroads With 401k Investors:”

Exchange-traded funds have been the hot thing in the investment world these days, but not among retirement plans.

That may be changing, as ETFs finally are gaining a foothold in the 401(k) retirement-plan market.

According to estimates from BlackRock Inc., the largest sponsor of ETFs, investors hold at least $2 billion of its iShares ETFs in 401(k) plans after buying about $500 million in fund shares last year.

Since iShares controls about half the ETF market, the figure suggests that in total there may be something like $4 billion of ETF assets in 401(k)s.

That is just a tiny sliver of the more than $1 trillion in 401(k) assets invested in mutual funds, but it represents significant growth from several years ago, when ETFs were almost entirely absent from these plans.
…

Since they mostly track indexes, which don’t tend to turn over much, and often swap stocks instead of buying and selling them, ETFs don’t tend to run up capital gains taxes that are passed along to their investors.

Exchange-traded funds have struggled in the 401(k) market because retirement plans neutralize some of their key advantages.

To keep brokerage commissions low, 401(k) plans typically pool many individual investors’ trades, eliminating participants’ ability to trade all day long. Also, retirement plans already allow investors to avoid capital-gains taxes, making ETFs’ tax benefits moot.

The exchange-traded fund industry has been arguing that ETFs should still be added to plans because of their low costs.

But there is a catch here, too. The 401(k) plans already include low-cost conventional index funds—typically large plans run by big companies—and thus don’t have much reason to switch.

For that reason, BlackRock’s iShares is focusing on small plans, typically those with less than $50 million in assets, says Greg Porteous, director of its 401(k) business.
…

Unlike large plans, which often offer mutual funds run by the same company that handles back-office “record-keeping” services for the employer, many smaller plans are overseen by a financial adviser. And as BlackRock points out, financial advisers are often fans of ETFs, making the sale easier than it otherwise might be.

“There’s not a lot not to like,” says Jerry Verseput, a financial planner in El Dorado Hills, Calif. He says he’s researched 401(k) plans recently because he’d like to add retirement-planning segment to his business.

In his experience, Mr. Verseput says, plans that include ETFs have tended to offer more transparent cost schemes and lower costs over all, factoring in both the costs of the funds and the costs to administer the plans.

Unlike other 401(k) options, ETFs don’t accommodate “revenue-sharing,” or using a portion of the fees investors pay to funds to support administrative costs of retirement plans.

Many financial advisers and consumer advocates think that is good news since it makes it easier to keep tabs on what investors are actually paying for.

But it doesn’t necessarily guarantee lower costs: Some plans add separate administrative fees to make up for the money lost from the lack of revenue sharing.

Still, ETFs’ future in 401(k) plans may be limited. Vanguard Group Inc., the third-largest ETF company, and also one of the largest retirement-plan providers, says so far it hasn’t included ETFs in its retirement plans, seeing no reason to displace almost-identical index mutual funds.

[My emphasis]

The last sentence says it all. It’s not about displacing almost identical index mutual funds. It’s all about investor flexibility to have the freedom of choice to move in and out of investments as he sees fit without not only being ridiculed but getting the shaft via ridiculous trading restrictions.

Vanguard and Fidelity are arguably the staunchest defenders of the buy-and-hold proposition no matter what market conditions are. Why? The answer is simple; because it’s good for their pockets but not necessarily for yours.

Actively Managed Income ETFs

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Actively managed ETFs seem to make the headlines now on a daily basis with more major players attempting to jump in the game. MarketWatch had this to say in “Pimco’s Active ETFs:”

Pimco has actively-managed mutual funds that seek to outperform a given index or benchmark by either having higher returns or by obtaining similar returns at lower risk. Now, Pimco has launched a series of exchange traded funds that are also actively-managed.

PIMCO Enhanced Short Maturity Strategy Fund (MINT):

PIMCO Enhanced Short Maturity Strategy Fund (MINT) is an actively managed exchange-traded fund (ETF) that seeks greater income and total return potential than money market funds, and may be appropriate for non-immediate cash allocations. MINT will primarily invest in short duration investment grade debt securities. The average portfolio duration of MINT will vary based on PIMCO’s economic forecasts and active investment process decisions, and will not normally exceed one year. MINT will disclose all portfolio holdings on a daily basis, and will not use options, futures, or swaps.

This is not a money market fund substitute for anyone needing ready access to their cash, but it is interesting alternative as a place to park cash and earn a bit better return. With an effective maturity of less than one year, it should have low volatility.
…

The second active ETF (MUNI) is a tax exempt bond portfolio, described by Pimco this way:

PIMCO Intermediate Muncipal Bond Strategy Fund (MUNI):

The Intermediate Municipal Bond Strategy Fund is an actively managed exchange-traded fund (ETF). Designed to be appropriate for investors seeking tax-exempt income, the Fund consists of a diversified portfolio of primarily intermediate duration, high credit quality bonds, which carry interest income that is exempt from federal tax and in some cases state tax. With this Fund, investors will see the names of the bonds owned daily. In addition, the Fund will not use options, futures or swaps.

I was puttering around on the Pimco web site looking for more information and eventually I made my way to a fairly new Pimco site exclusively for its ETFs. In addition to these active ETFs, Pimco has seven index ETFs that are covered on the Pimco ETF web site.

MINT has been trading since mid November 09 while MUNI has been offered since the middle of December. The ETFs are still trying to establish themselves and have low trading volumes. MUNI sports an average daily volume of 5,000 shares, while MINT does much better with 18,000 shares.

Still, much more time is needed (about 9 months) to observe price action and track trends, before I am willing to add these newbies to my database so that they can be featured in the weekly StatSheet.

The Dominator: Sell Stop Or Trend Line?

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

In regards to last Tuesday’s post “You Don’t Need A New High,” reader Fred was looking for more clarification:

Since you were on the subject of sell stops today, I have two questions related to it.

Do you recommend a single one size fits all sell stop percentage for all sectors, or do you use different percentages for different sectors?

Also, at what point would you use, for example – an index (like the Wilshire 5000) moving below its 200 Day MA instead of a sell stop to get out of a position?

The first part of Fred’s question has been discussed many times. I use a 7% trailing sell stop for broadly diversified domestic and international equity funds/ETFs. For more volatile sector and county funds/ETFs, I recommend using 10%.

However, if you were to invest in the W5k via an ETF or a mutual fund, you would not use its own trend line to make a buy/sell decision, but you would use the direction of the domestic TTI.

For example, back on June 3, 2009 when the domestic Buy was generated, you could have taken a position in the W5k. The markets moved higher but corrected in July, but never moved below the TTI’s long-term trend line again. That means you would have held on to your position unless your 7% trailing sell stop would have been triggered.

Right now, with the TTI hovering above its long-term trend line by +6.11%, there is mathematically no chance that it will drop below it before the 7% sell stop on the W5k gets triggered.

The TTI is a slow moving indicator, which will always lag the price movements of individual equity funds/ETFs. In other words, the sell stop will be your dominating guide as to when to get out.

Sunday Musings: A Sovereign Debt Crisis

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Forbes featured an interesting story by Nouriel Roubini titled “The Coming Sovereign Debt Crisis.” Here are some highlights:

In 2009, downgrades and debt auction failures in countries like the UK, Greece, Ireland and Spain were a stark reminder that unless advanced economies begin to put their fiscal houses in order, investors and rating agencies will likely turn from friends to foes. The severe recession, combined with a financial crisis during 2008-09, worsened the fiscal positions of developed countries due to stimulus spending, lower tax revenues and support to the financial sector.
…

In 2008 and 2009, the decisions by these governments to do “whatever it takes” to backstop their financial systems and keep their economies afloat soothed investor concerns. But if countries remain biased toward continuing with loose fiscal and monetary policies to support growth, rather than focusing on fiscal consolidation, investors will become increasingly concerned about fiscal sustainability and gradually move out of debt markets they have long considered “safe havens.”
…

Most central banks will withdraw liquidity starting in 2010, but government financing needs will remain high thereafter. Monetization and increased debt issuances by governments in the developed world will raise inflation expectations. These governments will have to offer higher real yields or investors will move to more attractive emerging markets.
…

The UK, Spain, Greece and Ireland will face sovereign risk pressures, especially if their fiscal imbalances are not addressed immediately. Some eurozone members are quickly approaching their debt sustainability limits as deleveraging through devaluation is not an option for these countries. Countries like Germany—whose fiscal imbalances have deteriorated largely due to the economic and financial downturn—might have a greater capacity to stabilize their debt ratio. The U.S. and Japan might be among the last to face investor aversion—the dollar is the global reserve currency and the U.S. has the deepest and most liquid debt markets, while Japan is a net creditor and largely finances its debt domestically. But investors will turn increasingly cautious even about these countries if the necessary fiscal reforms are delayed.
…

Developed economies will therefore need to begin fiscal consolidation as soon as 2011-12 by generating primary surpluses, which can be accomplished through a combination of gradual tax hikes and spending cuts. However, an aging population, a sluggish economic recovery and higher unemployment will keep governments’ entitlement spending high and revenues subdued. These factors might also make tax hikes politically challenging. Fiscal consolidation efforts might not be strong until the bond vigilantes signal shifting to safer assets.

[Emphasis added]

You can probably add a few South American countries, such as Venezuela, to the list of those facing sovereign risk pressures. While I agree that loose fiscal policies need to come to an end, I just don’t see it happen anytime soon.

The more likely consequence will be a financial blow up someplace in the world, which may unravel the current stock market rally. This has been my recurring theme for a long time not for the reason of me being negative, but simply being realistic.

We are living in an interconnected, changing world were no major catastrophic financial event remains localized. Everybody is connected with everybody else, and we are all affected by each other’s actions to varying degrees.

My point in these discussions is always the same. Don’t become complacent with your investments. Know your exit strategy and follow through executing your trailing sell stops whenever they are triggered.

More On Actively Managed ETFs

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

I am reading “Actively managed ETFs pique interest of big fund companies:”

The actively managed exchange-traded-fund market is expected to explode as top mutual fund companies, including Putnam Investments, John Hancock Funds LLC, T. Rowe Price Group Inc. and Pacific Investment Management Co. LLC, consider entering the business or expand their lineups.

The number of actively managed ETFs is likely to rise from the current 15 to more than 40, while the number of providers offering such funds could go from seven to 15, according to Rob Ivanoff, an ETF analyst at Financial Research Corp.

“Every big fund company is looking at this,” said Cindy Zarker, director of research at Cerulli Associates Inc.

Many asset managers have held off launching actively managed ETFs because of concerns about the effect that daily disclosure of their holdings would have on the shareholders of mutual funds that the ETFs mimicked. Other asset managers, while now unsure of demand for actively managed ETFs, want to hedge their bets in case mutual fund 12(b)-1 fees are abolished and brokers are more willing to try the new product.

For the most part, advisers have taken a wait-and-see attitude toward actively managed ETFs, intending to hold off until the products can post at least a one-year or three-year track record. But some say that reluctance may be ebbing.
…

Many investment management companies are discussing getting around the track record hurdle by converting their mutual funds to ETFs, said William M. Thomas, chief executive of Grail Advisors LLC, which has five actively managed ETFs.

“We are working with several mutual fund companies that are contemplating converting mutual funds to ETFs because they have solid, strong performance and are in a crowded marketplace where they are one of 250 large-cap-growth stock funds,” he said.
…

Pimco, which launched its first two actively managed ETFs last year, has registered to launch three more this year: the Pimco Government Limited Maturity Strategy Fund, the Pimco Prime Limited Maturity Strategy Fund and the Pimco Short Term Municipal Bond Strategy Fund.

The company also has had discussions about launching an ETF version of its giant Total Return Fund, said Don Suskind, a vice president and head of the ETF product management team.

[Emphasis added]

It’s an interesting concept that some mutual funds may convert to ETFs. That confirms my long-held belief that if mutual fund companies don’t come off their high horse and offer lower fees along with less restrictive trading policies, their days may be numbered.

If actively managed ETFs can attract enough followers over time, and offer a wide variety of low cost products, which they will, there would be no reason to ever buy a mutual fund again.

I am following these developments closely, but will not add any of these types of ETFs to my data base until I see at least 9 months of price history along with acceptable average daily trading volume. To me, that number has to be at least $4 million before I even consider modest exposure—assuming, of course, that the trends support such a move.

Overall, these are positive developments for the individual investor and for trend tracking in general. Of course, I can hear the new battle cry, which no longer will be whether mutual funds are better than ETFs, but whether managed ETFs are better than indexed ETFs.

As always, these comparisons are downright silly because the author usually has an axe to grind. I have found in the past that at times mutual funds will outperform ETFs and vice versa.

It’s more important to use the most appropriate instrument when making an investment. Momentum figures, such as I publish in the weekly StatSheet, may make it easier for you to make that decision.