Nothing Learned

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

A couple of weeks ago, MarketWatch featured a story titled “Don’t Just Do Something; Sit There.” Here are some highlights:

You learn in grade school that a correction fixes something that is wrong.

That’s why “correction” is such a difficult term when it comes to the stock market and investing, because the market is said to be in a correction when it is moving backwards after a big advance. But if the market is “correct” when it goes down, then it must have been “incorrect” when it was on the rise, and no investor likes that idea.

Confused? Well, stock market corrections have that effect on people.

Right now, judging from emails and message boards and letters I get from ordinary investors, there’s a real fear that what’s happening now is no mere correction, but the first step back toward the abyss, another leg down, the dreaded “double-dip recession” and more.

While I don’t know many investment pros who read the tea leaves that way, it’s important to know what to look at and think about if current conditions make you nervous and you suddenly believe that what is “correct” is to give up on what has been working.

Excuse me for asking, but what has been working? Most investors have been faced with a lost decade of buying and holding and are still reeling from the meltdown of 2008. It’s about time that people finally wake up and question old paradigms.

“Corrections are rogue; you don’t know where they are going to wind up and how long they will go on for, and that’s a big reason why they are scary,” said Walter S. Frank, chief investment officer for Moneyletter. “I don’t see what we’re going through right now as a reason to change allocations, but it’s hard for a lot of people to just stand still when they get scared.”

Famous last words! After two devastating bear markets in 10 years, a current rally based on smoke and mirrors, and this chief investment officer does not see a reason for changing allocations. That would be acceptable as long as an exit strategy exists to avoid a repeat disaster, but that is probably a foreign word to Walter Frank.

Indeed, when it comes to making portfolio changes, the underlying reasons to make a move typically can be linked to one or more of three root causes:

1) The market has changed.

2) The investment has changed.

3) You, the investor, have changed.

Most observers will tell you that market changes are the least important reason to make a move, but they are the one most investors react to. This is how an investor can have a financial plan, throw it away when the market takes a dive, and then miss out on the recovery.

Missing out on a recovery? Has it ever occurred to this writer that if you don’t participate in a downturn in the first place, you don’t need to recover? I have made this point numerous times after the meltdown of 2008. As of this writing, the S&P; 500 still needs to rise almost 20% to get to the level of our sell signal effective 6/23/08.

Everything is in place to make the current correction a short one. Corporate earnings may not be great, but they were so bad at the end of 2008 that the fourth-quarter numbers from 2009 only have to hurdle a low bar.

“I don’t know that things have gone down to turn this into a buying opportunity, and I won’t be surprised if things go down further before they look better,” said Frank. “But I know I wouldn’t be too worried about a correction when it happens in a bull market that looks like it will continue for awhile.”

Sure, corrections happen all the time; the problem is that you can never be sure whether they turn into something worse, like a move back into bear territory. Given what has happened in the market in 2008 along with a stock market recovery in 2009, odds are increasingly high that the downside will come into play again.

Unlike the recovery in 2003, economic fundamentals are horrible, debt on all levels is unsustainable and unemployment, a lagging indicator, shows no signs of improvement. Actually, unemployment will get worse as states, cities and municipalities struggle with budget shortfalls. Those potential layoffs have not been factored in current unemployment figures.

Be that as it may, the market could very well ignore all bad news and continue to climb a wall of worry. If it does, we will follow the trend until the end when it bends and stops us out of our positions.

To me, not having any exit strategy at all is asking for trouble and simply confirms that nothing was learned from the past.

No Load Fund/ETF Tracker updated through 2/18/2010

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

My latest No Load Fund/ETF Tracker has been posted at:

http://www.successful-investment.com/newsletter-archive.php

No negative front page news was good news, and the major indexes closed higher again for the second week in a row.

Our Trend Tracking Index (TTI) for domestic funds/ETFs has now crossed its trend line (red) to the upside by +3.78% keeping the current buy signal intact. The effective date was June 3, 2009.



The international index has now broken above its long-term trend line by +3.24%. A Buy signal was triggered effective May 11, 2009. We are holding our positions subject to a trailing stop loss.



[Click on charts to enlarge]

For more details, and the latest market commentary, as well as the updated No load Fund/ETF StatSheet, please see the above link.

An Experiment With Shorting The Market

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

The WSJ featured an interesting story with the intriguing title “An Experiment Shows The Risk Of Shorting.” Let’s listen in:

Back in late October, with stocks rallying, I decided to hedge some of my exposure by buying a “short” exchange-traded fund—an ETF designed to rise when the market falls. At the time, based on historical norms, the market was overdue for a correction.

After all, stocks had gone up nearly 57% without any correction of 10% or more since March, despite a sluggish recovery and rising unemployment. So I bought shares in the ProShares UltraShort S&P; 500 fund, which aims to double the inverse return of the Standard & Poor’s 500-stock index. In other words, for any given day, if the S&P; 500 fell 10%, this ETF would be expected to gain 20%. I wrote then, “I’m deliberately calling this an experiment, not a recommendation. I suggest that conservative investors let me be the guinea pig.”

The guinea pig is back with his report.

It’s long been my policy to avoid bets on short-term moves in the stock market. There are good reasons for this. No one else has been able to predict the market’s short-term direction with any consistency, so why should I? I only expected to hold the short ETF until a correction materialized, then sell.

And indeed, despite my expectations for a correction, none came. On Oct. 27 the S&P; 500 was at 1063; by Christmas it was 1126, a gain of 63, or 6%. My ETF, as expected, went the other way and lost more than twice that much, or 13%. So, as I reported on Dec. 23, I figured the market was even more ripe for a correction. I bought the ProShares UltraShort QQQ fund, which aims to achieve twice the inverse return of the Nasdaq 100 for a single day. At that point, the Nasdaq Composite was at 2253. Still, the market kept rising; the Nasdaq hit 2320 on Jan. 19.

Then I was vindicated—somewhat. By Feb. 5, the Nasdaq Composite had dropped as low as 2100 intraday, or just under 7% below its level when I bought the short ETF. The Nasdaq 100 had fallen similarly. I was looking at a gain of over 8% in my UltraShort QQQ shares. Coincidentally, the S&P; 500 fell to 1063 the previous day, right where it had been when I bought the UltraShort S&P; 500.

But then what? I hadn’t developed a clear-cut exit strategy. I had the idea I’d sell the short funds when the Nasdaq Composite had dropped 10%, a standard correction. But it never quite hit that threshold. Still, I no longer had the sense that stocks were so overvalued. Much had changed since October. Corporate earnings were rolling in, and they were strong. Multiple indicators suggested the economy was indeed improving. Despite the decline, the market seemed remarkably resilient considering all the bad news, such as worries about Greece defaulting. And then, the markets resumed their climb. Last week the S&P; 500 was back to 1076 and the Nasdaq to 2184.

I bailed out, a modest gain in my UltraShort QQQ shares offsetting a small loss in the UltraShort S&P; 500. With transaction costs, I pretty much came out where I would have been had I held cash.

The short ETFs performed as advertised, but I doubt I’ll be buying them again anytime soon. It may turn out I sold them prematurely, and that the long-awaited correction of more than 10% is just around the corner. But who knows?

The problem with selling short—which is really just the problem of selling, magnified—is you have to be right twice. You have to know when the market is overvalued, and then you have to know when a correction has run its course. I know there are many successful short sellers, but I don’t like those odds.

It’s obvious that the idea was to simply experiment with no clearly defined entry and exit points, so for that I appreciate the author being the guinea pig.

However, it brings up an interesting question, which has been asked by readers many times. How about selling short when the domestic TTI (Trend Tracking Index) crosses its long-term trend line to the downside and into bear market territory?

If you are an aggressive investor, you can allocate a portion of your portfolio to this approach. I found that there is a world of difference in looking at a chart with the benefit of hindsight and acknowledging that this point would have been a good one to short and actually implementing such a discipline.

What the chart does not tell you is the incredible volatility that you may have to face when taking a short position in bear market territory. Several readers shared their experiences with me back in 2008 when the bear struck and they went short. Violent market swings in both directions made that an endeavor for only the gutsiest of investors.

Nevertheless, I liked the author’s willingness to share the good with the bad, and it gave me the idea to do the same. My plan is that, once the domestic TTI breaks below its long term trend line and moves into bear market territory, I will take a position in SH (only for my personal account) and share my experiences with you.

To me, it’s not a question if we get to the bear market territory but only when.

Vanishing Fears

Ulli Uncategorized Contact



It’s not that the Greek debt crises disappeared over the Holiday weekend, but soothing words and lack of front page news were enough to alleviate or at least postpone fears of an imminent crisis. For the past 1-1/2 weeks, the market was headline driven and kicked around depending on the news from Europe.

No news was good news yesterday, and the major indexes, supported by a better-than-expected manufacturing index, along with a weaker dollar and a rally in commodities, did not hesitate and off to races we went.

While the rally was indeed impressive, we have to wait and see if this was a one-day wonder, or if short-term momentum has actually reversed. Major resistance for the S&P; 500 lurks around the 1,100 level, give or take a few points.

Mish at Global Economic Trends featured an interesting piece this morning, which resonated with me. It’s a lengthy article, but here is the summary titled “Something Is Brewing:”

Pressures mount as China attempts to walk a fine line between overheating and an economic bust accompanied by massive social unrest.

Elsewhere, central bankers assume the global economy is in recovery. In reality, the global economy is in another speculative binge fueled by reckless global stimulus, with China at the head of the pack.

Meanwhile, global imbalances grow with most eyes on Greece and Spain. Let’s not forget the massive property bubbles in Australia and Canada, and massive speculation in China. In the US, cities and states are on the verge of bankruptcy.

Something is brewing alright. That something is “trouble”, and not just for China.

That’s been my feeling for some time, which is why I don’t mind having a reduced exposure to the market due to some sell stops having been triggered last week. Once I can indentify that the major trend has in fact resumed, I will reconsider and add to my current positions.

Online Broker Commission Cuts Continue

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

The NYT featured an interesting article titled “What To Look For In An Online Broker,” which features a comparison of the major players in the business:

Charles Schwab fired the first shot when it cut its trading commissions last month, and now Fidelity and E*Trade have followed with price cuts of their own.

All of the changes may have made you think about switching brokers. Or, maybe you’re wondering if this should be a factor as you shop for a new brokerage account.

First, a quick review: Schwab cut its trading commissions to a flat fee of $8.95 in January. A few weeks later, Fidelity lowered its trading fees to $7.95. And last Friday, E*Trade said it would drop its fee to $9.99 or less per trade. None of them has cut prices below the $7 per trade charged by Scottrade, which remains the cheapest among the largest online brokers.
…

Why now? One reason the brokers cut commissions was to simplify their pricing and charge flat fees. Before the changes, Schwab, Fidelity and E*Trade all charged additional fees (about 1.5 cents per share) on top of their base commissions for people who traded more than, say, 1,000 or 2,000 shares, said Matt Snowling, an analyst who covers the online brokerage industry at FBR Capital Markets.

And as stock prices plummeted in late 2008 and early 2009, the size of the average trade in many widely held stocks increased. So it wasn’t unusual for investors to trade thousands of shares (think Citigroup at $3) — and that could add another $50 or so on top of the base commission. “The fact that none of the moves set a new price point below Scottrade is telling that we are not entering a true price war,” he added.
…

All of this is good news for the average investor. Lower trading commissions are always welcome, though these changes won’t really affect you if you don’t trade that often — and most long-term investors don’t (nor should they).
…

When you’re shopping for a broker, you need to consider the tools, services and funds they offer — that’s what really differentiates providers these days. For instance, while most brokers offer hundreds if not thousands of mutual funds, many will charge a “transaction fee” that can run up to $50 or more to invest in funds that aren’t on their “preferred” lists. So when you’re shopping around, make sure you won’t have to pay one of these fees to invest in your favorite funds. If you’re a fan of Vanguard index funds, for instance, you probably don’t want to invest in them through Schwab, which charges nearly$50 every time you make a deposit.

A 2009 study by J.D. Power and Associates asked more than 5,000 self-directed investors about their satisfaction with the major online brokerage players, and they ranked Charles Schwab at the top of the list. Vanguard came in second, followed by Scotttrade. Schwab’s customers were happy with its tools, account information, educational offerings, and interactions with its Web site. Vanguard, meanwhile, got high grades for its account offerings and phone-based interactions. And Scottrade received good marks for its trading charges and fees, as well as interactions through its branch offices.
…

The study also found that investors who used the tools and resources offered by their brokers were more satisfied than those who did not. That shows that price isn’t always the most important factor. Nor should it be.

If you are in the hunt of finding/evaluating a new online broker, I suggest you read the above link in its entirety.

Price wise there is not much difference so tools and resources may come into play for some. For example, if you are following the trend tracking method of investing, take a look and see if someone offers a simple but effective way to track your sell stops.

Or, if your work schedule has you on the road quite a bit, inquire about the possibility of using your cell phone as a trading tool, should you have the need to enter sell stop orders.

I agree that the decision of which broker you select should not be all about price, but mainly how you work and invest and who gives you the tools to best implement your investment strategy.

Is It Time To Sell Bond Funds?

Ulli Uncategorized Contact



One reader has a portion of his portfolio invested in bond funds and is wondering if they still make sense. This is what he had to say:

Do you have any insights and advise for people who are currently holding bonds such as MWHYX and PTTDX in their portfolios? While both of these funds have performed phenomenally over the past decade is now the time to consider dumping them?

In the past I have always been a big believer in having a bond component in my portfolio, and it has served me well.

With interest rates set to rise, and a “bond bubble” having formed should investors dump these bond funds from their portfolios?

First, eventually the “bond bubble” will bring down the stock market, unless it is pulled off its current level by another trigger.

Second, we don’t have higher interest rates yet; they are merely a known factor lurking on the horizon with no specific time frame. The Fed announced last week that “accommodating” interest rates are here to stay for the time being—whatever that means.

To me, the solution, as to whether you should sell your bond funds or not, is very simple. Follow the trend! Apply the customary sell stop strategy to bond funds just as you would to equity funds.

Take a look at the above chart in which I am comparing the funds you own with the S&P; 500. It’s obvious that your junk bond fund (MWHYX) tracks the S&P; 500 though with somewhat less volatility. The more diversified PTTDX has shown more stability during the downturn of 2008 and into 2009.

As a result, I suggest you use a 7% trailing stop loss for MWHYX and a lesser number, maybe 5% or so, for PTTDX. That way you don’t have to guess if now is a good time to sell or not. You simply let the market tell you when it’s time to exit.

Disclosure: I don’t have any positions in the funds discussed above.