Sunday Musings: Idle Cash

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Over time, I have received my share of emails from readers wondering how to deploy idle cash for which they have a short-term purpose. Here’s what reader TJ had to say on the topic:

I am in the process of having to deal with many renewing Certificates of Deposits from several institutions. My wife and I are in the process of building a home and need to have the cash available in the next 6 -12 months.

Obviously I do not want to take any undue risk with these funds, but I am seeking a larger yield than Fidelity’s Cash position of 0.70%. What is an appropriate parking spot for this cash? It is currently $500K and will ramp up to $1.2M by end of the year. Is the PCEF ETF appropriate for any of this?

I thank you for your past assistance.

Generally speaking, I am against “investing” funds that have a short-term need using a long-term investment discipline. All investment disciplines by nature are long-term to better deal with short-term market volatility.

Needing funds within 6-12 months for an important project such as a building a home requires safety first, unless you have very deep pockets. As I have recommended before, using instruments with no market risk such as CDs and money market funds are the only way to guarantee that your principal stays intact and will be available when you need it.

Income generating funds such as PCEF will bring market risk into the equation. While you may get lucky and hit a winning streak and make a decent return, it’s a bit of a gamble.

Here’s where you’re risk tolerance and overall financial situation comes into play. If you can afford to take some risk using income producing funds, and your capital is sufficient to weather out some potential losses (via rising interest rates) without jeopardizing your building project, then you could deploy a portion of your assets to funds like PCEF, BND or similar ones.

If you are asking me as an advisor if I recommend you go that route, the answer is no. Stick to what you have been doing and eliminate the stress that comes with market exposure, which will allow you to better focus on the project at hand.

Disclosure: We have invested positions in the funds mentioned above.

The “Value” Of Research

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Al Thomas, author of the book “If It Doesn’t Go Up, Don’t Buy It!” wrote in his weekly syndicated column about the “Attention Deficit Research Disorder.” Let’s listen in:

Wall Street has everyone, even the “experts”, believing the myth that research is required to be a successful investor.

Every fact about a company must be known before an investment is made. Find out the P/E ratio, management, cash flow, product quality, market share, etc., etc.

All the figures show the company is a “good” company, but that does not mean the stock will go up. Historical studies show there is little correlation between being “good” and the stock price going up.

After the investor has done his analysis he comes to realize all this information is an agglomeration of stuff that has no wisdom. Suppose you memorized the Encyclopedia Britannica. Would that make you wise? No. You just know lots of “stuff”. The key is you have to know what to do with it, how to apply it.

I make my income from trading. Would it help me to memorize the Morning Star Manual? Not really. It won’t tell me which stocks will go up. If all this “research information” is so valuable why aren’t all brokers rich? As a former brokerage company owner, I will tell you they are not.

Today there is so much information available it is staggering. Then you have to know if what has been found is true. Look at all the false material the financial wizards have been feeding the public.

Furthermore information travels at the speed of light through the Internet to any person who cares to read it. It is very difficult to keep a secret. There are whistle blowers everywhere, not that they are bad people.

Wall Street brokerage companies want you to do nonsense research so you won’t sue them when their “recommendations” turn out to be wrong.

There is only one thing you really need to know and that is the recent direction of the price movement of the stock. Is it going up, down or sideways? Look at a chart of the stock price for the last year or so. On the Internet you will find a chart and it will tell you more in 30 seconds than 30 days of intensive research.

The inundation of facts and figures can have the investor a nervous wreck. There is no need for emotional tribulation when you look at the price movement of the “good” company’s stock. It will be apparent whether it is good, bad or indifferent. If the trend is up, buy it. That is all any investor needs to know.

When it turns down sell it. Find another “good” company whose stock price is appreciating.

Financial research is worthless. If it created wisdom everyone would be rich.

While Al’s viewpoint certainly goes against popular thinking, I have to agree with him based on my experience. Fundamental analysis as it’s called may be able to tell you whether one company is financially in a better situation than another one, but it does not tell you whether it’s a good time to buy.

Say, you had spent weeks of research to evaluate a stock (or mutual fund) to the point that you were suffering from data overload, but you finally decided to make a purchase—in the summer of 2008. The market crash was about to instill some reality on Wall Street, and your carefully selected investment went down the tubes along with everyone else’s.

The point is that most research makes for an interesting conversation at a cocktail party while adding some aura to the person who can best throw around some terminology that others do not understand. It does nothing to provide you with a market entry point, nor will it assist you in getting out before the bear strikes again.

Follow the trends and stay on the “right” side of the market and employ a sell stop discipline no matter what you invest in. Keep your ego out of the way by acknowledging the fact that there is no shame in taking small losses from time to time, because they will keep you on the right track by providing a safety net that will prevent you from participating in market disasters.

No Load Fund/ETF Tracker updated through 3/25/2010

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

My latest No Load Fund/ETF Tracker has been posted at:

http://www.successful-investment.com/newsletter-archive.php

The major indexes eked out another gain despite failed rally attempts on Thursday and Friday.

Our Trend Tracking Index (TTI) for domestic funds/ETFs has now crossed its trend line (red) to the upside by +4.15% keeping the current buy signal intact. The effective date was June 3, 2009.

The international index has now broken above its long-term trend line by +6.28%. A Buy signal was triggered effective May 11, 2009. We are holding our positions subject to a trailing stop loss.

[Click on charts to enlarge]
For more details, and the latest market commentary, as well as the updated No load Fund/ETF StatSheet, please see the above link.

Active Or Passive Muni Bond ETFs?

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Tom Lydon at ETF Trends posted an interesting question in “Muni Bond ETF Debate: Active or Passive?”

Should an exchange traded fund (ETF) be created to beat the benchmark index or outperform it? Municipal bond ETF providers are butting heads over the polemical issue of whether ETFs should offer an investor pure exposure or provide investment know how.

As it stands, the majority of providers such as BlackRock, State Street Global Advisors, Van Eck Global and Invesco Powershares believe passive is the way to go. Those landing on the active side of things include providers such as PIMCO, Grail Advisors and most recently Eaton Vance.

By the end of January, there were 27 muni ETFs available with $6.19 billion in assets. Prior to 2009, all muni ETFs were passively managed – the ETFs bought bonds in a target index and tried to provide a 95% correlation with the index.

Bond holdings in passive muni ETFs only represent a small portion of the overall bond index. Passive muni ETF portfolio managers aim to reflect the benchmark index through “representative sampling.” The portfolio managers would break down the index into categories like credit risk, duration and maturity, and weight the fund with bonds that recreates the aggregate risk characteristics of the benchmark.

PIMCO, like other actively managed ETF providers, believes that a portfolio manager should devote his or her time to research and beat the market. PIMCO launched its first actively managed ETF last year, the PIMCO Intermediate Municipal Bond Strategy Fund (MUNI). The fund has a published benchmark index but only uses it as a comparison. Grail Advisors shortly followed with its own intermediate fund, the Grail McDonnell Intermediate Municipal Bond ETF (GMMB). Most recently, Eaton Vance has registered to launch a series of actively managed funds.

Actively managed muni ETFs provide investment expertise of an established manager at a lower cost than mutual funds and greater transparency. For instance, Grail’s muni ETF has an expense ratio of 0.35% while the average mutual fund fee is 0.9%.

More important than the active vs. passive argument at this point is whether these issues are even worthy of investment consideration. The 2 funds mentioned above (MUNI and GMMB) are tiny in size ($20 million and $5 million) as well as extremely weak in volume.

I did not even bother to look at the bid/ask spread, because most of these new offerings need some time to establish themselves in the market place. My rule of thumb is that I want to see at least 9 months of price data to be able to look at their trends and make comparisons. That’s the time where you can revisit the idea as to whether active beats passive or not.

Right now, I simply acknowledge that these ETFs have come on the market, but would not consider them investment quality. It goes without saying that I have no holdings in any of the ETFs mentioned above.

Mutual Fund Fee Makeover

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

The NYT featured an article titled “Mutual Fund 12-b1 fees Could Get a Makeover.” Here are some highlights:

Many investors might skip over the line on their mutual fund disclosure statements that says, ”12b-1 fee.”

They might want to start wondering what’s behind that label. These fees are the money that many funds collect to offset a variety of expenses, from advertising to broker’s commissions. They can cut into investors’ returns.

The fees, whose name is a legacy of the Securities and Exchange Commission rule that created them three decades ago, brought in $9.5 billion for fund companies last year. That amount is equal to 18 percent of all fund expenses, not counting sales charges, according to the fund industry’s Investment Company Institute. The 12b-1 fees typically amount to around $2 a year for every $1,000 invested.

The SEC is questioning whether investors should be paying them. Chairwoman Mary Schapiro has asked her staff to present a recommendation on 12b-1s for the commission to consider this year. Schapiro’s predecessors have studied possible 12b-1 changes, but there haven’t been any overhauls.

Schapiro sounds serious. ”Investors may have no idea these fees are being deducted, what services they are paying for, or who they are ultimately compensating,” she said in a speech last month.

Broadly, the SEC says 12b-1s are supposed to cover fund distribution, and in some cases, shareholder services. These expenses frequently aren’t covered by the sales charges that many funds assess, or the management fees all funds charge for overseeing an investment portfolio.
…

And a fund that doesn’t compensate advisers through a 12b-1 is probably collecting that money elsewhere. Increasingly, 12b-1s have become revenue substitutes for the growing number of funds that don’t charge ”loads,” or sales fees. A fund touting itself as ”no-load” may be hitting you up in the form of a 12b-1 or another expense after you buy in.

”It doesn’t make sense to use 12b-1s alone as a tool to screen out funds,” says Mercer Bullard, president of Fund Democracy, a fund shareholder advocacy group. Bullard is a former assistant chief counsel at the SEC.
…

Besides compensating brokers, 12b-1s were created to help a then-struggling fund industry recover from tough times in the 1970s. The thinking went like this: 12b-1s could help funds cover marketing and advertising costs to lure back investors. The more assets the funds have, the more efficiently they’ll be run, leading to expense cuts that can benefit all. Eventually, many funds could become big enough that their governing boards would decide to stop charging 12b-1s.

But it often hasn’t worked out that way, because of the varied arrangements that fund companies use to compensate brokers selling their funds. Take American Funds, which assesses 12b-1s at its biggest funds. That includes the nation’s largest stock fund, Growth Fund of America, whose biggest share class (AGTHX) charges a 12b-1 fee of 0.24 percent. That’s about one-third of overall expenses at the 36-year-old fund, whose assets now total $156 billion.
…

American Funds spokeswoman Maura Griffin said the company views 12b-1s ”in part as a method of compensation for transaction-based financial advisers for their ongoing advice and service to their clients.”
…

ICI, the industry group, says scrapping 12b-1s would eliminate incentives for advisers to continue serving clients, for example, by giving them investment advice. A 2005 study by ICI found that only 2 percent of 12b-1 fees supported advertising and other promotions. About 40 percent went to advisers for initial sales, with 52 percent for ongoing support.

”The vast majority of 12b-1 fees are for compensating advisers for services they provide, and investors want,” ICI chief economist Brian Reid says.

But the National Association of Personal Financial Advisors — whose members are compensated on a fee-only basis without commissions — applauds Schapiro’s 12b-1 review.

”When you peel back the layers, you see that some mutual fund companies are making a profit on 12b-1 fees,” says NAPFA Chairman William Baldwin.

Schapiro says the fees may have made sense when they were introduced in 1980. But now, she says, ”it is past the time to reassess their need and their effectiveness.”

I agree that the original idea of 12b-1 funds may have had merit, but an overhaul of this old law is in order especially if these fees are no longer used for their intended purpose.

To increase profits for mutual fund companies in a roundabout way, that is not transparent to the investor, is simply not acceptable. Additionally, if you purchase such a fund directly, and some of these fees are at times (at the fund’s discretion) used to pay a commissioned broker, then you should not be paying for “services” you don’t receive.

According to the above article, 12b-1 expenses seem to have turned into a kind of a slush fund for mutual fund companies to be used as they see fit. In today’s environment of transparency and disclosure, this is an area that definitely needs to be improved.

One Reader’s 401k Issues

Ulli Uncategorized Contact

Reader Scott experienced some changes to his 401k set up and is considering a couple of choices. Here’s what he had to say:

My question concerns my 401k account through work. We have been fully invested with Vanguard funds; however, we have recently been forced to transfer all our funds to T D Ameritrade brokerage since Vanguard is no longer supporting small company 401k accounts at its brokerage.

This all fine except that after the first year at Ameritrade all the Vanguard funds will incur a transaction fee to trade in or out of. This will be unacceptable in my opinion so I need to change something.

I have researched correlated NTF funds to replace the Vanguard offerings with, but they carry higher expense ratios, usually .50 to 1.00 higher than the Vanguard fund.

Do you think I would be better off to switch to an all ETF portfolio and incur the commission for each trade up front, or go with the NTF funds with the higher expenses?

You are actually very fortunate to have that choice. Many 401ks do not offer ETFs at all leaving the participants stuck with mutual funds and their (at times) severe trading restrictions.

Personally, I would go with the ETF set up; no questions about it. Trading costs are negligible these days, especially if your investment horizon is long term and you don’t engage in day trading.

It’ll also make it easier to follow my trend tracking approach, if you’re so inclined, along with the use of trailing sell stops. My weekly StatSheet will provide you with the backup information to hopefully assist you in making more successful investment selections.