Several readers emailed comments regarding last Saturday’s post covering ETFFX. Here’s what Glenn had to say:

It looks like they are using something similar to a 60 day SMA of SPY to make decisions. Sometimes they apparently are not 100% ‘in’ though, resulting in underperformance in an up market. And looks like they occasionally use some other criteria, or don’t follow the plan and underperform too, e.g., early November-mid-December 09.

Still, they more or less equaled SPY performance from 10/06 (apparently before it was available for purchase) to end of 07, out-performed by a large margin during the downturn, and then under-performed during the bull starting in March 09.

Thanks for passing this along. It may be a worth a try for some passive investing.

While I don’t know what methodology they use, it’s important to note that they did avoid the brunt of the 2008 crash, which is what really matters. Here’s the chart again comparing ETFFX vs. the S&P; 500 vs. the total bond market index:

Let’s assume for a moment that ETFFX is somewhat representative of what trend tracking is all about. It will smooth out the investment ride for you by limiting (not avoiding) losses by being on the sidelines when bear markets strike. Because it is a defensive way of investing, you will lag during bullish periods because of the effect of sell stops during pullbacks and the incremental move back into the markets.

If you are looking for outperformance during bullish periods, you will very likely not see it. Given that, how do you then outperform the S&P; 500? Very simple; only by combining the returns during bullish AND bearish phases in the market will you come out ahead.

Here’s an interesting anecdote. A reader called me at the end of 2009 and shared with me the following story: He had been with an advisor who grew this portfolio at a rate of 35% per year for 3 years straight.

Upon my inquiry as to why he was calling me, since I don’t generate those kinds of returns, he hesitantly replied “well, in the fourth year, I lost 80%.”

If you put a calculator to these numbers, you will conclude that, despite 3 years of incredible returns, he ended up losing half of his original investment. Now he has to make 100% on the balance just to get back to a breakeven point.

The moral of the story is that profits are meaningless, unless you have a way to protect them when sentiment changes from bullish to bearish.

My latest No Load Fund/ETF Tracker has been posted at:

http://www.successful-investment.com/newsletter-archive.php

Sideways meandering left the major indexes almost unchanged from last week, but up for the month of July.

Our Trend Tracking Index (TTI) for domestic funds/ETFs held above its trend line (red) by +2.50% (last week +2.62%) and remains in bullish mode.

The international index has now broken above its long-term trend line by +1.32% (last week +1.16%). A new Buy Signal was triggered 7/23/10 with the effective date being 7/26/10. Be sure to use my recommended 7% trailing sell stop discipline should you decide to participate in this new uptrend.

For more details, and the latest market commentary, as well as the updated No Load Fund/ETF Tracker StatSheet, please see the above link.

The battle of earnings vs. economic data continued yesterday as the markets declined slightly but essentially went nowhere.

The Fed’s beige book simply repeated what Fed chairman Bernanke already elaborated on over the past couple of weeks that the economy has lost some steam with not much hiring going on in addition to continued sluggish real estate markets.

As far as upward market momentum is concerned, we have stalled. The S&P; 500 has been dancing around its widely watched 200-day moving average (currently at 1,114) but has not made any meaningful advances above it.

Technically speaking, we have been range bound, and a positive piece of economic news is needed to push us onto higher ground. In the absence of such support the path of least resistance will be to the downside.

The question is wide open at this point as to whether the 1,114 level will continue to serve as resistance, and the top of the rally, or become a new consolidation point to function as a springboard for more gains.

Because if this uncertainty, I have not yet removed the short component of our hedge nor have I added any new positions based on the recent international buy signal. Avoiding a potential whipsaw is important during this sideways period, and I’d rather be a little late to the party than too early.

Maybe the reports on weekly jobless claims and U.S. economic growth due out later this week will give some clue as to which direction the major trend will take.

After the recent run, the markets took a breather yesterday with the S&P; 500 resting right on its 200-day moving average of 1,114. Attempts of breaking above that level proved to be ephemeral in nature as the 1,121 level was only touched and sideways movements prevailed for the remainder of the session.

Not helping matters was a gloomy report on consumer confidence with the index hitting its lowest level in five months. That should come as no surprise as the jobless rate is anticipated to hover around the 10% level for the foreseeable future.

Last time I checked money for consumer spending and home purchases is usually derived from earned income via a job. In the absence of any improvement in that arena, prospects for a solid recovery remain a mirage.

Be that as it may, the indexes did not sell off yet after the recent run up, which could be considered a bullish sign. However, it remains to be seen if the failing faith in the economic recovery will eventually be noticed by Wall Street and play itself out via a trend reversal.

While I believe the odds of this happening are great, right now I will treat this up move with great respect (with only limited additional exposure) knowing that through my lens the fundamentals simply do not justify these lofty levels.

As I mentioned in last Friday’s weekly update, the International TTI (Trend Tracking Index) crossed its long-term trend line to the upside, and a new buy signal was generated effective Monday, July 26, 2010.

If you decide to participate, be sure to use ETFs (as opposed to mutual funds), if you can, should this cycle to turn out to be a head fake.

Reader Ken had the following question regarding this latest buy signal:

Can you tell me a little more about the makeup of the International TTI so that I can pick the most representative Funds/ETF’s for the buy signal? For example, does it represent the Global Market ex U.S., or is it more narrowly focused? Does it include an Emerging Markets component that would make an ETF like VWO appropriate?

In the absence of any information about the make-up of the International TTI, I have been considering VEU, GWL or CWI but have been wondering if they are too broad based and if something a little more narrowly focused and matching the TTI would be a better choice.

While the TTI composition is proprietary, I want to point out again that the international signal applies to all “broadly diversified international equity funds/ETFs.” That means from your list VEU, CWI and GWL are suitable for this signal, but VWO is not. I would classify VWO to belong into the Country Fund category, for which a fund’s individual trend line crossing should be used as a signal.

No matter which fund/ETF you decide to use, it’s imperative that you implement my recommended 7% trailing sell stop discipline in case this buy signal turns out to be short-lived.

Disclosure: No holdings at time of writing

In last Friday’s market commentary, I talked about the fact that we have reached the upper band of the recent trading range and that a potential break above the S&Ps; 200-day moving average could mean a resumption of the bull market.

This level could also present major resistance and pull the indexes off their lofty levels. Reuters reports more on the subject in “Stocks on brink of breakout:”

Wall Street enters next week on the cusp of a breakout in U.S. stocks, but it will need another spate of convincing earnings reports to feed the rally that sprouted at the end of this week.

Analysts will also digest the results of the European stress tests on banks. But if Friday’s session is an indication, market movement will likely be muted.

What is has come down to is a battle of earnings vs. economic data. The bond market rally indicates that slower economic times are ahead. The recent stock market rebound supports the opposite. Both can’t be right!

We have to wait and see how this battle plays out in order to see which direction the next long-term trend will take. Right now, it’s anyone’s guess.